On Tuesday, at one minute to three, the bishops’ radio station, COPE, broadcast its daily afternoon editorial. That day El Hierro, an island of twelve thousand inhabitants, had seen around eleven thousand arrivals in seventeen days, according to the station itself at midday, and the residents’ association of La Restinga had resigned en masse. The editorial was not about El Hierro: it was about Rwanda. Germany, Denmark, Greece, the Netherlands and Austria had announced on Monday in Vienna a centre in that country for people who have no right to remain in Europe and whose countries of origin will not take them back, and the radio dismissed it as “a highly problematic decision that is difficult to reconcile with international law.” “Rwanda is by no means a safe country,” it declared, warning that the entire European legal framework “is at risk of collapse in the face of a real problem, but one that requires appropriate solutions without giving in to panic” (in La Restinga, they know a little more about panic than in the studio). In the end, to round things off, it quoted Leo XIV. But only half of it.
The editorial continued with the law: the Geneva Convention, the European Convention on Human Rights and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the Union “prohibit the deportation of migrants and refugees to countries such as Rwanda.” None of the three texts names any countries. They prohibit returning someone to a place where they risk persecution or ill-treatment, and whether Rwanda is one of those places is precisely what is under discussion (the British Supreme Court said it was in 2023, regarding London’s plan). According to the Austrian chancellor, the model was prepared with the Commission, the International Organization for Migration and UNHCR, the agency responsible for overseeing the Geneva Convention. If the chancellor is telling the truth, no one had sent the editorial to UNHCR.
Then came the history lesson. “The Geneva Convention arose precisely after the great displacements that occurred following the First World War,” the station explained, adding that “after what happened in Europe in the Second World War, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights enshrined the principle of non-refoulement.” Both sentences have a problem. International protection for refugees was indeed born in the days of the League of Nations, but the Geneva Convention dates from 1951, after the Second World War, and the principle of non-refoulement is in its Article 33. The Universal Declaration of 1948 does not include it: it recognises the right to seek asylum, which is something else. Two world wars and two texts, and the editorial swapped them around with the aplomb of someone who puts Easter before Lent.
Of the European Return Regulation, approved this year with Spain voting against, it said that it “already represented a step backwards from the gains generated by the moral conscience of the old continent.” And it found the cause of the problem: “Let us not forget that Europe’s low birth rate and need for labour are the main cause of the pull effect.” Not the mafias or the regularisations: Europe’s empty cradles. It is a thesis with notable pastoral consequences, because it turns family pastoral care into border policy (with more baptisms in Spain, presumably, fewer cayucos would leave Senegal). Four hours later, the same station broadcast the passage from the speech by Luis Argüello, president of the Episcopal Conference, on “collapsed birth rates.” No one joined the dots.
The end of the editorial was for the Pope. “The words of Leo XIV in the port of Arguineguín still resonate,” it said, and made them resonate like this: “Human dignity demands legal and safe pathways, rescue and assistance.” In Arguineguín, on 11 June, that sentence did not end there; it continued: “real cooperation against traffickers, effective protection for victims, serious processes of reception and integration.” In the same speech, Leo XIV said that “while there is a right to seek refuge when life is threatened, there is also the right not to have to migrate,” and spoke of “the mafias that traffic in despair.” They did resonate, yes, but with the equaliser on: the treble was heard and the bass was lost. Nor did the Catechism resonate, which in number 2241 recognises that political authorities, mindful of the common good, “may subordinate the exercise of the right of immigration to various legal conditions.” The editorial signed off with a concession: “Migrations must certainly be managed, without forgetting our identity as Europeans.” The “certainly” came at the end, like the small print.
At ten past four, La Tarde travelled to the other shore. Pilar García Muñiz interviewed Lucía Pérez, coordinator of the Diocesan Delegation for Migration in Senegal, for ten minutes. She described serious work: accompanying the families of the dead and the missing, warning young people of the risks, training them so there is something to do at home. She also spoke of the “organised networks” that profit from the journeys, and the presenter asked whether they advise young people to seek an outlet in their own land. But the first thesis of the interview was another, and it passed without rebuttal: “freedom of movement is ultimately a human right that has been violated for a long time,” with the figure that more than half of Senegalese are denied visas. The Universal Declaration recognises the right to move freely within a State and the right to leave any country, even one’s own. The right to enter another does not appear. On the bishops’ radio, a denied visa is already a violation of human rights.
In Arguineguín, Leo XIV called for legal pathways, cooperation against traffickers and respect for the right not to have to migrate. The editorial on the bishops’ radio, in two minutes, only had room for the first.
“COPE, the bishops’ radio” is a daily section of InfoVaticana. We listen carefully to our bishops’ radio and tell you what we find: advertising, guests, language, what is said and what is left unsaid. COPE is 75% owned by Ábside Media, the company the Episcopal Conference created in 2020 with its shares and those of most dioceses. The Jesuits and Augustinians are also shareholders. Each Spanish bishop is personally responsible for what is broadcast on it. Read also