Hungarian bishops ask forgiveness for the clergy who collaborated with the communist secret police

The files opened by the Péter Magyar Government include clergymen such as Cardinal Paskai; the bishops warn that appearing in them does not prove collaboration

Hungarian bishops ask forgiveness for the clergy who collaborated with the communist secret police
András Veres, presidente de la Conferencia Episcopal de Hungría

The Hungarian Episcopal Conference has asked forgiveness from the victims of the clergy who collaborated with the secret police of the communist regime, following the opening of the State security services’ archives. “In their name, we ask forgiveness from the victims and their families”, the bishops state in a declaration released on November 4, the same day the files were made public. Among the names appearing in the archives are, according to EWTN News, those of Cardinal László Paskai and Archbishop István Seregély.

The files, which Prime Minister Péter Magyar described as a long-delayed revelation, contain around 60,000 names of informants. Their publication has reopened the debate in Hungary about the past of public figures from various fields, including several clergy members.

The episcopal statement, reported by the Catholic portal Vasárnap, begins with the teaching of Saint John Paul II on the purification of memory and the healing of the wounds of the past. The bishops maintain that making the files public can be a step in that direction, provided it does not lead to simplistic conclusions or be used to destroy specific individuals.

The text distinguishes between cases. The bishops acknowledge that some of the clergy listed did in fact collaborate with the regime and passed on confidential information about other members of the community, and it is in their name that they ask forgiveness. But they recall that others were tortured or blackmailed, that some wrote reports without substance, and that others were merely targeted for recruitment, refused, and were still recorded. They add that part of the documentation was destroyed, so the preserved material does not offer a complete picture.

The bishops also emphasize that the main responsibility lay with the liaison officers, the leaders of the party-state, and those who actively supported the dictatorship, not with the people who were recruited. They place the issue within the context of the persecution suffered by the Church: according to the statement, more than a hundred priests and religious died, around 2,000 were imprisoned or confined, most religious orders were banned, and some 11,500 religious were left without means of livelihood; communities, youth movements, and associations were dissolved, and nearly all Church schools were nationalized.

The conclusion is a call not to judge hastily. Social reconciliation, the bishops say, must be based on truth, and it is not appropriate to condemn anyone without knowing their full story. The response to the wounds of the past, they affirm, is recognition, forgiveness, and mercy, not contempt, revenge, or hatred.

As the bishops themselves warn, the appearance of a name in the files does not by itself prove collaboration, and some cases had already been settled in the courts. The Diocese of Szeged-Csanád has described as false, misleading, and illegal the rumors about the alleged recruitment of its bishop, László Kiss-Rigó, based on a security services file, and has recalled that in 2009 he won a lawsuit for the protection of his personality rights in which the court did not find it proven that he had been an agent, according to the Hungarian portal Portfolio.

The Hungarian case joins other similar processes in former communist countries, where the opening of the political police archives has forced the Churches to review the conduct of part of their hierarchy under the dictatorship, seventy years after the 1956 revolution was crushed by Soviet tanks.

The Hungarian bishops ask forgiveness for the clergy who denounced others, but warn against hasty judgments.


Read also

Help Infovaticana continue informing