Bertomeu admits he proposed criteria and names for the Pope's meeting with victims in Lima

The commissioner of the Sodalicio case tells Alfa and Omega that the final decision was made by "other Vatican instances"; victims and farmers from Catacaos ask the Pope for another meeting before leaving Peru

Bertomeu admits he proposed criteria and names for the Pope's meeting with victims in Lima
Jordi Bertomeu

The pontifical commissioner for the Sodalicio case, Jordi Bertomeu, has acknowledged that he participated in the preparation of the meeting between Leo XIV and abuse victims at the Apostolic Nunciature in Lima, although he attributes the final decision to others. In an interview published this Saturday by Alfa y Omega, the official of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith explains that “I was asked to make suggestions about the criteria that should be followed”, that he proposed some names, and that the final decision belonged to “other Vatican instances,” without specifying which ones.

The interview is published two days after the Pope received six victims, some linked to groups related to the Sodalitium of Christian Life, in a meeting from which José Enrique Escardó, the first public whistleblower of the organization, was excluded. He described it as a deception and had already blamed the nuncio and the Peruvian Episcopal Conference for his exclusion. Bertomeu does not mention Escardó. When asked about the complaints of victims who were not invited, he responds: “Yes. Unfortunately, it happens frequently.” And he adds that the meeting “must be an open door, not a new frontier”.

The commissioner describes the Lima meeting as “a moment of great consolation for the survivors and, also, of hope,” but warns of the risk that it may remain just a gesture: “Listening that is not translated into concrete decisions runs the risk of becoming a new disappointment”. What the victims demand, he says, is “truth, justice, recognition of the harm, and reparation,” and reparation must also include financial compensation. According to his data, there are more than 250 victims of the Sodalitium.

Regarding the liquidation of assets, Bertomeu maintains that the goal is for those responsible for the abuses to make available to the liquidating commissioner the assets necessary to compensate the victims. He acknowledges that it is not easy to convince them, says he cannot detail the steps to obtain those resources, and points out that alleged financial irregularities and a business network linked to the group are still under investigation, which may require the support of civil authorities. It will be necessary to determine, he adds, whether the assets offered for liquidation truly correspond to the group’s former patrimony. “What cannot be tolerated is that the victims are deceived once again by those who should take responsibility for the harm caused”, he states. A week ago, in an internal letter to the victims, the commissioner had already postponed the reparation indefinitely until the Holy See’s bodies have “sufficient certainty” about the canonical legality of the economic activities of the suppressed group.

In the same interview, Bertomeu describes the founder, Luis Fernando Figari, as “a young Peruvian of classist and far-right orientation,” heavily influenced by the Spanish Falange, and recounts, according to testimonies received by the special mission, surgical interventions on young people, including ovary removals, treatments with psychotropic drugs, pressure to marry after leaving the group, and job offers in linked companies as a form of dependency. He says he has known Leo XIV since he was bishop of Chiclayo.

The commissioner’s words coincide with a new request from the victims. This Saturday in Chiclayo, less than five hundred meters from the cathedral and about two hours after the Pope crowned the Immaculate Virgin, a group of Sodalitium victims, peasants from Catacaos, and members of the organization Ending Clergy Abuse called in a press conference for a meeting with Leo XIV before he leaves Peru, according to the agency Efe, reported by Religión Digital. The peasants from Catacaos, in Piura, claim they were stripped of their lands by companies linked to the Sodalitium and that its suppression did not end them. “Reparation is not an act, it is a process”, said Matthias Katsch, a victim of abuse at a religious school in Berlin. The complainants demand the dismantling of the group’s economic structure and want to deliver a letter to the Pope before he boards the plane.

There is no record of a response from the Holy See to that request. Francis suppressed the Sodalitium in 2025; a year and a half later, financial reparation to the victims remains pending, and the person coordinating the process admits that the final word on the meeting was not his and that it is not easy to gather the assets with which it must be paid.

Bertomeu proposed criteria and names for the Lima meeting, but says the decision was made by others.


Read also

Help Infovaticana continue informing