The archbishop and Foucauld's radio: "Some of us call Him God, others Allah, others the universal energy"

In the weekly interreligious dialogue section of Ràdio Estel, a guest presented the idea that without the Church there is no salvation as a “closed” mentality, and the host found it “very interesting.” Foucauld wrote that in Islam “the truth was not there.”

The archbishop and Foucauld's radio: "Some of us call Him God, others Allah, others the universal energy"

At 6:23 p.m. on Friday, November 20, Ràdio Estel opened «Temps de diàleg», the section that its religious current affairs program, «Sense distància», devotes each week to ecumenism and interreligious dialogue. The host, Ignasi Miranda, announced the purpose: «Today we want to learn about a very special way of living the Christian faith and also, in some way, why not say it, interreligious faith». The guest was Núria Miralles, of the Little Sisters of Jesus, with missionary experience in North Africa, and the topic was St. Charles de Foucauld, the hermit of the Sahara canonized in 2022.

Miranda asked her what was special about Foucauld’s way of living the faith. The religious sister replied that he was «a prophet for us, today», ahead of his time, because then «the human mentality was very closed, especially the Church». And she explained it this way: «It was said that without the Church there is no salvation. Everyone believed they possessed the truth. He, on the other hand, saw very far». The proof was a prayer of the saint, «My God, make all humans go to heaven», which the guest glossed in this way: what Foucauld wanted was the unity in diversity of all humans, «but that we meet in the love of Christ, and some of us call him God, others Allah, others the universal energy, but for him all people of good will, if they went along the path aware of what they were and doing good, we all met in that God who is unique».

No one corrected anything. The host responded «Yes, yes, very interesting this reflection» and sought support for it in the Gospel: that connected very well, he said, with chapter 17 of Saint John, «where there is that dialogue of Jesus with God the Father». He also drew the moral: «That here we can all meet, it is a message for everyone, whatever culture they have, as you say».

The prayer is authentic, and its history is another. René Bazin, the saint’s biographer, recounts that Foucauld began with it, «My God, make all men go to heaven», each of the twenty-one lessons of his catechism for the people of the desert. It was the first line of a catechism, not a dispensation so that the name would not matter. Regarding Islam, moreover, Foucauld himself left his judgment in writing. In 1901, newly ordained a priest, he told his friend Henry de Castries how he had recovered the faith and what he had thought of that religion which had so impressed him in Morocco: «I liked Islam very much, with its simplicity, simplicity of dogma, simplicity of hierarchy, simplicity of morality, but I saw clearly that it lacked divine foundation and that the truth was not there».

Nor is what the guest dismissed as a closed mentality from another time. The declaration Dominus Iesus, published in the year 2000 by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith with the approval of John Paul II, establishes that «it must be firmly believed that the “pilgrim Church is necessary for salvation”», and excludes «that indifferentist mentality» which ends up thinking that «one religion is as good as another». The Church teaches that Muslims worship with Christians the one God and that whoever, without fault, does not know the Gospel and seeks God with a sincere heart can be saved. It does not teach that universal energy is another name for God. And from the desire that all go to heaven, Dominus Iesus does not draw the radio’s conclusion, but the opposite: «the certainty of God’s universal salvific will does not diminish but increases the duty and urgency of proclaiming salvation and conversion to the Lord Jesus Christ». That is why Foucauld went to the desert.

Miranda closed the section with a conclusion: «We have discovered that dialogue between religions and cultures does not need great speeches or solemn declarations», and thanked the guest for a «very edifying» conversation. The Church has, precisely, a solemn declaration on this. It is called Dominus Iesus, and in it is also the answer to the label with which the section opened, «interreligious faith»: «Therefore, the distinction between theological faith and belief in other religions must be firmly held». As for chapter 17 of Saint John, which the host brought in support, its third verse says what eternal life consists of: «that they may know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom you have sent». Of universal energy, the verse says nothing.


«Ràdio Estel, the archbishop’s radio» is a daily section of InfoVaticana. We listen attentively to the radio of the archbishop of Barcelona and tell you what we find: advertising, guests, language, what is said and what is left unsaid. Ràdio Estel belongs to the Fundació Missatge Humà i Cristià, linked to the Archdiocese of Barcelona and presided over by its archbishop.

The archbishop of Barcelona is responsible for what is heard on it.

Read also

Help Infovaticana continue informing