José Ignacio Munilla has launched a bet on X that he has already won. “I bet Putin and Trump won’t say a word about this to Xi Jinping!”, wrote the bishop of Orihuela-Alicante about a headline from Religion in Freedom: China bans minors from entering churches, with cameras, controls and detained catechists. They won’t tell him. But the message is missing an addressee. The one who has signed an agreement with Xi’s government on the Church in China for eight years is neither the White House nor the Kremlin. It is the Holy See.
The occasion is the summit that this Thursday brought together Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific forum. The announced agenda spoke of nuclear disarmament, the Middle East and trade. Nothing about catechesis, and Munilla is right to point it out. The information he shares comes from AsiaNews, the agency of the Pontifical Institute for Foreign Missions: signs banning minors at church doors, surveillance of entrances on Sundays and, on November 7 in Zhejiang, four catechists punished with ten days of detention for teaching the catechism in private homes.
What the message does not say is who is watching those doors. According to the same AsiaNews, it is done, among others, by personnel from the Catholic Patriotic Association, the body through which the Communist Party oversees the registered Church. In Henan, the circular that in 2018 closed churches to minors was signed by the official Catholic bodies of the province, according to the agency, Wang Yuesheng, ordained bishop of Zhengzhou in 2024, and Li Jianlin, ordained bishop of Xinxiang in 2025. Both were appointed by pontifical nomination, within the framework of the agreement. In December 2025, the seal that closed a church in Xuchang for allowing minors to enter bore the seals of the Patriotic Association and the Commission for Ecclesiastical Affairs. In Shanghai, summer catechism courses were banned and the ban was tightened after the arrival of Shen Bin, transferred there in 2023 without papal appointment and later confirmed by Francis; today he presides over the Council of Bishops and has been the principal consecrator of three of the nine Chinese bishops of this pontificate.
This structure also includes the last bishop to emerge from the agreement. This Wednesday, José Liu Hengping was ordained in Xiamen, appointed by Leo XIV on October 15. He is the twentieth since 2018 and, according to official Chinese sources, vice-president of the Catholic bodies of Fujian, including the Patriotic Association. The biography released by the Holy See Press Office only mentions his parishes. The text of the agreement, extended three times and in force until 2028, remains unpublished.
Rome has not lacked opportunities to speak. On October 27, Archbishop Paul Richard Gallagher, head of relations with States, admitted that “the imperfections of the agreement are evident” and maintained that the situation is better than before it was signed. On November 5, Cardinal Pietro Parolin inaugurated a congress at the Urbaniana University in which Li Shan, bishop of Beijing and president of the Patriotic Association, participated. In April, Human Rights Watch sent its conclusions on the repression of Catholics to the Holy See and the Chinese government and requested comments; when it published them, neither had responded. Regarding the children whose church doors are closed, there is no public word from the Secretariat of State. Not a peep.
Munilla may reply that China is far away and that he has not signed anything with Beijing. That is true. What he signed, on May 6, 2020, as bishop of San Sebastián and together with those of Bilbao and Vitoria, was an agreement with the Basque government on the conditions for returning to Mass after almost two months without public worship: one-third capacity, people at the door to organize entries, an invitation to the elderly to delay their return and a commitment to tighten measures if the health authority requested it. In the Basque Country, the dioceses had taken the lead, with Vitoria being the first in Spain to suspend Masses, and the regional government decreed on March 14 the cessation of all activity in places of worship. The state decree of that same day did not go so far: it conditioned attendance on maintaining a one-meter distance. By then the Episcopal Conference had already recommended, the day before, following Mass through the media and had suspended in-person catechesis. It is not the same, and it is worth saying before he does: that was general, sanitary and temporary; what is happening in China is ideological, permanent and targets children. But the Basque agreement was published. The one between Rome and Beijing has gone eight years without anyone being able to read it.
Munilla’s question is good and deserves an answer. It only lacks one name on the list. Trump and Putin can be reproached for not speaking with Xi about Chinese children. The Holy See, which has been talking with Beijing for eight years, should be asked about what. As for the agreement, not a word has been published either.
Read also