By Stephen Daisley
On November 11, with Pope Leo XIV’s twelve-day apostolic journey through South America at its halfway point, the Argentine daily La Nación noticed something. According to its report, the slogan “Freedom for the traditional Mass,” or its variant “Young people want the traditional Mass,” had accompanied the Pope across the country on flags and banners: along the route to the Monument to the Spaniards, where he celebrated a massive open-air Mass; at the gates of the Apostolic Nunciature, where he spent every night; and at the youth vigil in Palermo.
If you are not Catholic and are scratching your head at this point, rest assured that most Catholics are doing the same. We are about to enter the darkest—some would say obscurantist—of worlds: the Latin Mass Controversy.
By “Latin Mass” we mean the Roman rite as it was celebrated for nearly a millennium, through a succession of gradual reforms, with a universal Roman Missal promulgated in 1570 by order of the Council of Trent; hence its other name, the Tridentine Mass. In the 1960s—how could it be otherwise—evolution gave way to revolution, and under the auspices of Vatican II, though going far beyond what that wise council had foreseen, the liturgy was upended.
The Mass ceased to be said in Latin and moved to the vernacular. The priest turned his back on liturgical east, the direction of God, to face the people. Prayers were shortened and simplified; the psalm Iudica me (“Judge me, O God”) and the Last Gospel, the prologue of Saint John (“In the beginning was the Word”), simply disappeared. The age-old Gregorian chant gave way to more recent hymns, sometimes Protestant, and to contemporary praise music born of the folk revival of the sixties. The communion rails before which the faithful knelt to receive Holy Communion on the tongue were removed, and Catholics began to queue, standing, to have the Body of Christ placed in their hands.
Despite the disconcerting nature of these changes, this form of the Mass, known as the novus ordo, was and remains canonically valid as the ordinary form of the Roman rite. It is the Mass celebrated by John Paul II, the one that carried Saint Carlo Acutis to Heaven, and the one that sustained the faith of millions under the communist yoke. Yet among a small but committed minority of Catholics, the longing for the Mass as it had been persisted. John Paul II granted some leeway, but it was not until 2007, under Benedict XVI, that the Tridentine Mass was once again opened to the faithful. The German Pope explained it this way: “What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us as well, and it cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful.”
The new norms changed nothing about the Mass Catholics attended each week or each day; in fact, most of the faithful were unaware of Benedict’s letter, Summorum Pontificum. It did not oblige priests to celebrate the Tridentine Mass or the laity to attend it. It simply meant that, where they wished, clergy could publicly celebrate the ancient Mass without having to seek permission from their bishop. In the years that followed, interest in the Tridentine Mass grew steadily: older Catholics returned to the Eucharistic celebration of their formative years, and younger generations encountered for the first time an ancient liturgy that had been boxed up and stored in the attic in the sixties.
The traditional resurgence unsettled the Church’s progressives, and in 2021 Pope Francis promulgated the apostolic letter Traditionis Custodes, which revoked the permissions granted by Benedict and required priests who wished to celebrate the Tridentine Mass to seek authorization from their bishop. It was a devastating blow to Catholics of a traditional sensibility, who saw the Mass that nourished their faith taken away by bishops fearful of schism and perhaps resentful of what seemed a reaction against the work of their entire lives at the head of the Church.
Some had hoped that Leo XIV, regarded as more measured than Francis, would ease his predecessor’s restrictions, especially after the Holy See declared the traditionalist Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X to be in schism and excommunicated its bishops for consecrating new bishops in defiance of its orders. Given the more than dubious claim of the Fraternity to be the true custodian of the Tridentine Mass, it seemed sensible for the Vatican to prevent the schismatics from carrying the Church’s timeless liturgy out the door in their pockets. Which brings us back to that banner.
On November 16, during the in-flight press conference on the return to Rome, the Holy Father gave what sounded like a definitive answer to a journalist and, by extension, to the young Catholics who had brandished that ubiquitous banner in Argentina. Asked whether he intended to relax Traditionis Custodes, he replied:
“No, not at this time. Traditionis Custodes was a decision of Pope Francis and we will continue to apply it. Traditionis Custodes provides for the possibility of dispensations or of allowing the Tridentine Mass, the Vetus Ordo Mass, to be celebrated, and so, once again, for the unity of the Church, the vast majority of Catholics throughout the world celebrate the rite of Vatican II, that of Paul VI, and we will continue to do so, and there is an open path for those who wish to request the dispensation.”
Although Leo’s words appear to close that possibility, any seasoned Vatican-watcher would note the phrasing, from the opening “not at this time” to the distancing formula “a decision of Pope Francis.” Even so, traditionalists will not be able to talk their way out of this. The Pope has spoken, and until he or a successor says otherwise, his word is law.
Yet in today’s Church the hierarchy commands far less deference than in generations past. Social changes play a role, but so does the residual radiation of the clerical sexual-abuse scandal: episcopal authority has been diminished in the eyes of the faithful by the morally disordered judgments some bishops made when confronted with evil. So even though the Holy Father has spoken, others will continue to speak as well, and those voices will say the same thing those banners in Argentina said: “Young people want the traditional Mass.”
For progressive Catholics, generally baby boomers and older members of Generation X, it is frustrating to find themselves where all victorious revolutionaries end up: as the status quo against which a new generation inevitably rises. Where they rebelled against tradition, Generation Z Catholics yearn for more tradition. Where they sought relevance, the young crave reverence.
Few of them reject the novus ordo, and even fewer reject Vatican II. They have simply found in the ancient usage the pieces missing from their spiritual puzzle. In a noisy, insistent age in which the constant hum and alerts of technology push toward another profane hit of dopamine, the Latin Mass offers a sanctuary of sacred silence; against the disorienting bombardment of modernity, relativism, and ideology, a shield of eternity, doctrine, and fidelity; amid the strident temptations to worship the self, an invitation to the humility of worshipping God. Young people, in Argentina and elsewhere, want the traditional Mass because it gives them what the world cannot: the mystery of faith.
Demographics are not destiny, at least not in an institution like the Catholic Church, but they matter. Baby boomers are aging, clergy and laity alike, and their failure to pass on the faith to the generation or two that followed is driving the Church toward a precipice in rectories and pews. Many churches will close; parishes will merge; some dioceses will be absorbed by others; deacons and laity will have to assume more responsibilities, and the Mass will become a scarcer sacrifice, because in some places it will no longer be possible to sustain daily celebration.
When that moment comes, the Church will depend on those traditional young people, by then well into middle age, and their more orthodox instincts will inevitably reshape Catholicism. The 2025 National Study of Catholic Priests in the United States found that while more than 70 percent of those ordained before 1975 described themselves as “progressive,” the situation had reversed 180 degrees since 2010: more than 70 percent of priests ordained since then describe themselves as “conservative.” Only 11 percent of those ordained before 1980 considered access to the traditional Mass a priority, a figure that rises to 39 percent among those ordained after 2000. The Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter, a society of apostolic life in communion with Rome that celebrates only the traditional Mass, is recording record numbers of ordinations. Only one-quarter of young Catholics attend Mass every week, but the proportion jumps to 98 percent among those who attend the Latin Mass. A formidable tide is rising.
Leo XIV is right to want to safeguard the unity of the faithful, but as the faithful change, so too will the contours of that unity. Among those who occupy the pews every Sunday, devote their time to running parish groups, and fill the collection basket, an ever-greater proportion will ask that both expressions of the Mass be available: the living one, the novus ordo, and the enduring one, the ancient Mass. Saint Augustine said: “For you I am a bishop, with you I am a Christian.” The distinction structures the Church hierarchically, but true unity lies in what is shared. The bishops of tomorrow, guided by the Holy Spirit, will stand with the faithful in understanding respect for tradition and for the traditional Mass as a communion between what was, what is, and what will always be.
About the author
Stephen Daisley is a regular contributor to The Spectator and a columnist for the Scottish Daily Mail. This article was originally published in The Spectator.
Read also
- Leo XIV ratifies Traditionis Custodes: “It was a decision of Francis and we will continue to apply it”
- The young people behind the banner to Leo XIV: a document, a rosary, and 5 reasons to free the traditional Mass
- The Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter surpasses 600 members, with 410 priests and an average age of 39