The Apostolic Signatura examines the appeal of the Gaztelueta professor against Satué's canonical sentence

José María Martínez appealed in April 2025 the conviction for abuse of a minor handed down by the current bishop of Málaga, and the tribunal presided over by Mamberti must confirm or revoke it

The Apostolic Signatura examines the appeal of the Gaztelueta professor against Satué's canonical sentence
Foto: user:Lalupa / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura is examining the appeal filed by José María Martínez, the Gaztelueta school teacher, against the canonical sentence for abuse of a minor signed by José Antonio Satué, then bishop of Teruel and now of Málaga. This is reported in advance by El Confidencial Digital, which places the matter “under study” in the highest tribunal of the Holy See for administrative and procedural matters, presided over by Cardinal Dominique Mamberti.

An appeal filed in April 2025

According to that publication, which cites sources close to the case, Martínez filed the appeal on 29 April 2025 together with his lawyer, a few weeks after being notified of Satué’s sentence in March of that year. On 3 March 2026, the Signatura replied by letter that it had completed its study of the appeal, but required two prior steps: payment of the fees and accreditation of a Rotal lawyer. Those formalities were completed in the following weeks, so the procedure continues.

The tribunal must now decide whether to accept the appeal and overrule the bishop of Málaga, or to uphold the sentence. Martínez wrote on his blog, whose last entry is dated 3 March 2025, that the Signatura was the “only instance that can stop this absurdity.” Since then the Pope has changed, and Leo XIV, who is a canonist, renewed part of the tribunal in July 2026 with five-year appointments, including bishops Salvatore Cordileone, Edward M. Lohse and Juan Ignacio Arrieta, and canonists Eduardo Baura, Krzysztof Nitkiewicz, Gianpaolo Montini and Ulrich Rhode.

A process reopened by Francis and questioned by the defense

The canonical process was reopened by decision of Pope Francis, who in September 2022 entrusted the case to Satué, then bishop of Teruel and Albarracín. Martínez had been investigated through canonical channels and acquitted in October 2015, while the Spanish courts convicted him at first instance to eleven years in prison, a sentence reduced by the Supreme Court to two years for lack of sufficient evidence on the most serious facts. The events judged date back to 2008 and 2010.

Martínez’s defense and some experts denounce serious irregularities in the procedure. Canonist Rafael Palomino, in his report, describes it as an ad hoc disciplinary procedure rather than a true penal trial, and suggests that the sentence may have responded more to external pressure and media impact than to procedural guarantees. Already in 2023, a decree of the Signatura signed by Mamberti rejected an earlier appeal by Martínez’s lawyers, which raised procedural issues, including the recusal of Satué.

A civil lawsuit against Satué, pending judgment

At the same time, Martínez maintains an open civil lawsuit in a court in Pamplona against Satué for violation of his right to honor. According to El Confidencial Digital, the judge admitted the case, the bishop is listed as a defendant, and the trial was concluded for judgment on 5 May, awaiting resolution.

InfoVaticana has followed the case from the beginning. At the time it reported the criticisms of jurist Benigno Blanco regarding the lack of procedural guarantees in the ecclesiastical sentence, and exclusively advanced the appointment of Satué as bishop of Málaga.

Help Infovaticana continue informing