The Málaga Hope brotherhood puts itself at the service of the PP eight days before the elections

Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo, Feijóo’s number two for Madrid and a declared agnostic, was given a standing ovation at the lunch of the Bolsa de Caridad de la Esperanza and turned the devotion into an electoral slogan. Sergio Morales and his board must explain who invited her and in what capacity.

The Málaga Hope brotherhood puts itself at the service of the PP eight days before the elections

The Archconfraternity of the Paso and the Esperanza of Málaga had only one task on Saturday: to seat 280 people at the table so that its Charity Fund could assist those who have no table. It ended up serving as a backdrop for the Popular Party’s campaign. Eight days before the general election, Alberto Núñez Feijóo’s number two for Madrid entered the Throne Room amid applause, and the video of the scene later appeared on her X account under a slogan in capital letters: “With HOPE in MÁLAGA. For HOPE in SPAIN”. No one has distorted those images. They were shared by the candidate herself, with the accounts of the PP of Málaga and the Andalusian PP tagged at the bottom. And whoever governs a brotherhood is responsible for what happens in its house.

The sequence is that of a party agenda. That same Saturday, Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo, deputy spokesperson for the Popular Group in Congress, took part in a PP forum at the NH hotel in Málaga alongside Elías Bendodo, candidate for the province; Patricia Navarro, provincial president of the party, and the mayor, Francisco de la Torre. She called for a massive vote for her party and spoke of recovering “decency, coexistence and hope”. The hotel and the Throne Room are on the same street, San Jacinto, a few steps apart. At two in the afternoon the XXXIV Charity Lunch of the archconfraternity began there. Local television 101TV reported that the leader was received with applause and that she was attending a lunch “to which she had been invited”. She thanked the brotherhood for the “moving welcome”. The word that closed an electoral promise at the forum was, in the tweet, the name of a Virgin put to work for that promise.

There are two possible explanations, and neither reflects well on the governing board presided over by Sergio Morales, re-elected as elder brother in June with 876 votes. If the archconfraternity invited her, it remains to be seen in what capacity. Álvarez de Toledo is not a candidate for Málaga, has no known ties to the brotherhood and has described herself as: “I am agnostic, but tradition belongs to everyone and I recognise myself in it”. An invitation from the board is not a private gesture: it commits a corporation with nearly 3,800 voting brothers, each of whom will vote as they wish on 29 November. If the board did not invite her and she arrived at the hand of a guest or her party, the archconfraternity is not off the hook either. A board that has a chief of protocol, three vocal members and a deputy for the branch does not discover by surprise who enters its Throne Room in the middle of a campaign, who is filming and for what purpose. And whoever only wants to help the Charity Fund has more discreet ways: the Gospel asks that the left hand not know what the right hand is doing and advises against blowing the trumpet in front of everyone.

The reproach would apply to any party. During Holy Week it was the socialist candidate for the Junta, María Jesús Montero, who toured brotherhoods across half of Andalusia in the middle of the pre-campaign, two of them in Málaga, and the brotherhoods received her. Andalusian confraternities have for too long confused dealing with institutions, which is inevitable, with serving those who occupy them. The Esperanza has additional reasons of its own to be especially careful. The Great Procession that in May 2025 took its Virgin through the streets of Rome cost more than 2.3 million euros, around 80 % of it public money, according to The Objective. The Junta de Andalucía contributed about 700,000 euros; the City Council of Málaga, 300,000, and the Provincial Council, another sum, according to the figures published at the time. All three administrations are governed by the PP. None of that proves a payback of favours. Precisely for that reason, a brotherhood that has travelled with everyone’s money cannot afford to appear to be returning it in applause.

There is a second layer, and it is the one that should worry a public association of the faithful. The list on which Álvarez de Toledo is running in second place is headed by a candidate who, on 11 November on El Hormiguero, settled the issue with a phrase: “On the abortion law I am not going to make amendments”. On Friday, the eve of the lunch, the bishops closed their Plenary without a statement on the vote, because the text did not reach two-thirds, and their president, Luis Argüello, published on his own a decalogue whose third point calls for protecting all human life “from conception to natural death”. While the shepherds could not agree on what to say to Catholics, in the Perchel they were answered with applause. In the Throne Room there was no need to ask for the vote. It was enough to stand up.

Canon law does not regulate lunches, but it clearly states where it wants parties to be in relation to the brotherhoods: far from their governance. Canon 317 §4 excludes from the presidency of public associations of the faithful ordered to the apostolate those who hold leadership positions in political parties. The statutes that the Málaga brotherhoods have been adapting to the 2019 diocesan decree repeat the same clause, which bars governing boards to presidents, secretaries general and senior officials of parties and unions. The diocese of Jerez has gone further this year: since September, anyone holding a leadership or spokesperson position in a party may not even deliver a pregón. None of these rules prohibit seating a candidate at the table, and it is worth saying so before the board does. What they all take for granted is that the brotherhood does not belong to any party. That is what ceased to appear to be the case on Saturday.

The sensible thing would be to acknowledge it. It was a mistake, it is said and the page is turned; making a mistake does not dishonour anyone. What is not acceptable is to remain silent while the video circulates with the signature of a candidate asking for votes. Sergio Morales and his board owe their brothers three answers: who invited Álvarez de Toledo, in what capacity, and whether the archconfraternity is going to ask that its house and the name of its titular image be removed from electoral propaganda. The hope venerated in the basilica of the Perchel is a theological virtue: it is placed in Christ and admits no party acronyms. The Nazareno del Paso blesses all of Málaga every Holy Thursday in the Plaza de la Constitución, without asking anyone what ballot they are carrying. In his house, eight days before the polls, a candidacy was applauded standing. Someone has to explain why.


Read also

Help Infovaticana continue informing