Digital Religion campaigns against individual confession with episcopal money

A priest from Bilbao warns the Bishop of Vitoria on Religión Digital that normalizing individual confession empties parishes. Church institutions have been buying space on that portal for years.

Digital Religion campaigns against individual confession with episcopal money
El Papa revisa documentos en un encuentro informal, reflejo del ambiente de análisis en la Iglesia.

Once again. Religión Digital publishes this Saturday an op-ed by Jesús Martínez Gordo, a priest of the diocese of Bilbao and a regular contributor to the outlet, who asks who is emptying our parishes and answers in the headline itself: normalizing individual confession ends up weakening the community. The target is the bishop of Vitoria, whose sin has been to announce that there will be a priest hearing confessions before Mass and to say that he wants to normalize the sacrament. That a website claiming to be Catholic presents the confessional as a pastoral problem is what one would expect from it. That this website has been running advertisements for Church institutions for more than a decade, without any bishop having lifted a finger to stop it, is a disgrace. We are tired of writing it. We write it again.

Juan Carlos Elizalde said it on November 4, in the homily at the installation of Father Francesco as pastor of Arechavaleta, according to the quote collected in the op-ed itself: his Advent pastoral letter will state that, except in exceptional cases, a priest will be available to hear confessions half an hour before Masses, and he called for normalizing penance in the diocese as something liberating. It is the only concrete measure mentioned in the text, and Martínez Gordo claims he has no objection to it. What unsettles him is the verb. It is worth reminding him what is being normalized. The Code requires everyone entrusted with the care of souls to offer their faithful individual confession on days and at times that are accessible to them (canon 986). John Paul II asked in 2002, in the motu proprio Misericordia Dei, that bishops and pastors periodically verify that these facilities truly exist, and specifically recommended that confessors be available before Masses. Elizalde has not designed any strategy. He has fulfilled a law and heeded a saint.

The trick of the op-ed lies in a missing word. Martínez Gordo grants individual confession a legitimacy and an ordinary character that, according to him, the Church recognizes in it, and asks that it not be absolutized. The Church does not recognize it as ordinary. It recognizes something far more uncomfortable for the author: individual and integral confession and absolution are the “only ordinary way” by which the faithful conscious of grave sin are reconciled with God and with the Church (canon 960; Catechism, 1484). If that is absolutizing, the absolutization comes from Trent, which defined under anathema that confessing each and every mortal sin is necessary by divine law. In Martínez Gordo’s pen, Tridentine functions as an insult. In the Church it is the name of an ecumenical council. John Paul II left no loophole: the complete confession of grave sins, he wrote, “in no way can be left to the free judgment of Pastors,” and he specified in parentheses what was excluded: dispensations, interpretations, local customs. Martínez Gordo invokes precisely the last item on the list: the pastor cannot limit himself to applying a general strategy, because not all parishes are the same. Local customs.

Martínez Gordo recounts that faithful from neighboring parishes where individual confession is already almost the only modality attend the communal celebrations of his pastoral unit. He does not say what is celebrated in them, which is the only thing that matters. The ritual knows two communal forms. In the first, after a common liturgy, each penitent confesses his sins to a priest and receives absolution one by one. If that is what is done in his pastoral unit, there too there is individual confession, and the absolutization he denounces does not exist. The second, general confession and absolution, the Code reserves for danger of death without time to hear each penitent and for grave necessity, which is the lack of confessors for the number of penitents and not the large crowd on a feast day; it is judged by the diocesan bishop according to the criteria agreed upon in the Episcopal Conference, and leaves standing the obligation to confess afterward, one by one, the grave sins (canon 961; Catechism, 1483). Either the op-ed defends something that already contains what it criticizes, or it defends as ordinary alternative what the Church only admits as exception. John Paul II described in 2002 what was observed in some regions: a tendency to abandon personal confession, hand in hand with the abusive recourse to general absolution. Twenty-four years later, what empties the parishes, according to the op-ed, is that the confessional becomes normal.

The op-ed speaks of aged and fragile communities, of embers, and warns that each faithful who leaves weakens what little remains. Elizalde pronounced the words that so unsettle the theologian when he installed Father Francesco as pastor, who arrives with two other young priests from the Pilgrims of the Eucharist, aged 28 and 32, to the youngest neighborhood of Vitoria: four thousand residents with an average age of 34. The theologian looks at the embers and points to the confessional. The bishop looks at a neighborhood of young families, sends him three priests and announces confessors before Mass. Martínez Gordo closes with canon 1752, the salvation of souls as the supreme law, and demands that the bishop answer for the fruits. The fruits of this sacrament are not counted in attendees at a celebration. They are counted in reconciled souls. The Catechism explains, in the same number that speaks of the only ordinary way, why the Church insists on personal confession: Christ addresses each sinner personally. “Son, your sins are forgiven you,” he says to the paralytic of Capernaum. His friends had lowered him through the roof; the community brought him there. The forgiveness was given to him.

There is only one creature to whom it matters that Catholics end up seeing in the confessional a threat to the community. The Curé of Ars waged war on him for thirty-five years, at night, so that he would not sleep; when his bed caught fire, the saint merely remarked that the devil, since he could not catch the bird, was burning the cage. Today he does not need to burn anything. It is enough for him that a priest explain, canon in hand, that normalizing the confessional empties the parishes, and that a Catholic website publishes it. The same website that in May gave a platform to the letter of the “52 priests” against this bishop, which according to the diocese carried two real signatures, from two retired priests. The same one that in 2016 welcomed him as the candidate of the Munilla and Rouco circle. The one that declares on its homepage that it sails with Golias and Adista. That website has an agenda and displays it for all to see. At this point, calling it demonic is not an exaggeration. It is a description.

What is intolerable is not Religión Digital, which is what it is and says so every day. What is intolerable is who buys space from it. In 2014 we published the screenshots: the campaign of the X of the Episcopal Conference, Cáritas, Manos Unidas and the Pontifical University of Comillas, advertising on its pages. In 2018 we reported that several diocesan foundations of Madrid, presided over by Cardinal Osoro, had contracted a three-thousand-euro annual banner through the Delegation of Foundations of the archdiocese. The archdiocese ended up attributing the payment to some foundation, not to the diocese. Some foundation. When ACI Prensa asked the Episcopal Conference about its economic links with the portal, the response was that the Conference runs advertising campaigns in the Spanish media and, when pressed, that “your question has already been answered.” Comillas, at least, acknowledged having paid for ads. Between October 2025 and January 2026, Religión Digital published a string of sponsored pieces from UMAS, the mutual that insures the Church, the same one with which the president of the Episcopal Conference signed the agreement that made it the official insurer of the Pope’s visit and whose assembly of mutualists this year was closed by the secretary general of the Conference. The mutualists who requested the figures have not received a response, as far as we know.

To this portal, the agency that manages the digital advertising of the Episcopal Conference offered in 2025 a campaign in which two of our articles were flagged because they were “against the client’s interests.” We reported it and rejected it. It is not on record that in that ecosystem anyone has ever found a text from Religión Digital that goes against the client’s interests. Nor this one.

We have been writing this article for twelve years, with screenshots, with figures and with questions that no one answers. It is disgusting to have to repeat it. Every euro that a Church institution leaves on that portal sustains an op-ed in which the confessional is a problem and the bishop who opens it, a suspect. To the Curé of Ars, the devil had to burn his bed. Today a column is enough for him. And we do not know a single bishop who has said in public that this is a disgrace.


Read also

Help Infovaticana continue informing