Moroccan males aged 14 to 17 multiply the Spanish conviction rate by 7.8

A study by Carlos III University of Madrid has analyzed approximately 434,000 offenses committed by minors with final convictions between 2007 and 2023, according to the nationality of each individual. Moroccan males show a rate 7.8 times higher than that of Spaniards, and Latin Americans, 2.3 times higher. The author argues that the category "foreigners" conceals very different realities.

Moroccan males aged 14 to 17 multiply the Spanish conviction rate by 7.8

The work is signed by Jesús Javier Sánchez Barricarte, professor in the Department of Social Sciences at Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, and is published by the Revista Española de Investigación Criminológica. It is based on the INE’s Statistics on Convicted Minors, whose Confidentiality Committee provided the data, and on the registered population aged 14 to 17. According to the author, no previous studies had compared minors convicted in Spain by specific nationality. The rates are adjusted for age and sex to allow comparison between groups with different demographic structures.

Figures by nationality

The gender gap is very large: boys commit on average 4.5 times more offences than girls. That is why the analysis focuses on males. Among them, the Spanish rate is 1,887 offences per 100,000 young people. The Moroccan rate reaches 14,710—7.8 times higher—and the Algerian rate is 12,500, 6.6 times higher.

The Latin-American group has a rate of 4,303, 2.3 times the Spanish rate, with wide differences between countries. The Dominican Republic (3.6 times) and Colombia (3.1) lead the group. Ecuador (2.4) and Venezuela (1.7) fall in an intermediate zone. Peru (1.3) is close to the national average, and Mexico (0.8) is even below it.

Foreigners as a whole multiply the Spanish rate by 2.7, but the author considers this figure “scarcely informative” because it mixes very different realities. Young people from the European Union stand at 1.5 times the Spanish rate. Those from several Asian countries are below the Spanish rate: Pakistanis at 0.4 and Bangladeshis at 0.3.

From theft to sexual offences

The difference appears in every type of offence. In property crimes, which account for 46.5 % of the total, the Moroccan and Algerian rate is 9 times the Spanish rate, and the Latin-American rate is 2.3 times higher. In assaults and offences against persons, the ratio is 7.8 versus 2.6. In sexual-freedom offences, there are 232 offences per 100,000 Maghrebi youths, 78 among Latin Americans and 31 among Spaniards.

Homicide is the only category in which the Latin-American group exceeds the Maghrebi group: 26.2 per 100,000 versus 24.6, with a Spanish rate of 3.7. It is a very rare offence: only 0.23 % of recorded offences.

The study also provides a figure that has weighed in the public debate. Between 2017 and 2023, 27 Spanish minors and 11 foreign minors were convicted of rape—4.3 and 17 cases per million, respectively. Sánchez Barricarte warns that these are very few cases and that the figures can vary greatly from year to year. He also notes that, over the whole period, recorded sexual offences rose by 161 % among Spaniards and fell by 31 % among Moroccans and Algerians.

A hierarchy that does not change

Rates generally decline over the series and nationalities tend to converge, but the order barely changes over seventeen years. Moroccans and Algerians remain at the top. They are followed by Latin Americans and sub-Saharan Africans. Europeans, Spaniards and the rest of foreigners occupy the lowest levels. The article itself acknowledges a “less favourable trajectory” in the Maghrebi group.

To explain this difference, the author examines several hypotheses. The first is that the police monitor certain groups more closely. He accepts that this may inflate the figures for all foreigners, but believes it does not explain the Maghrebi difference: sub-Saharan Africans, equally visible, have a rate 2.1 times the Spanish rate. He also points to poverty, which affects 77.1 % of minors of Moroccan origin compared with 19.2 % of native-born youths. Another possible explanation is the presence of unaccompanied minors: according to his calculations, 7.5 % of Moroccan and Algerian males aged 16 and 17 were unaccompanied in 2021-2022. However, sub-Saharan Africans are also numerous among these minors and have much lower rates. Living in cities is likewise not an explanation: only 46.1 % of Moroccans and Algerians live in cities of more than 50,000 inhabitants, compared with 52.3 % of Spaniards.

Regarding religion, the author rules out that it explains the difference. His argument is that other majority-Muslim nationalities, such as Senegalese or Gambian, have much lower rates, and Pakistani and Bangladeshi rates are even below the Spanish rate. He also cites studies showing that religious practice somewhat reduces delinquency, including among European Muslim adolescents. The study, however, does not measure religiosity. This conclusion is based on comparing nationalities and on the works it cites.

What the data do not say

The article stresses its own limitations. It only counts offences that end in a final conviction. It excludes unreported crimes and cases resolved without trial. It records legal nationality, not origin, so children of immigrants who hold Spanish nationality are counted as Spanish. The provincial analysis also finds no solid relationships with income, unemployment or population composition when Ceuta and Melilla are excluded.

The title of the work refers to “empirical evidence versus social alarm,” and in its conclusions the author calls for caution to avoid stigmatisation. Even so, his own tables show that recorded juvenile delinquency among Moroccan and Algerian males has remained far above the Spanish and Latin-American rates throughout the period. The author calls for studies with individual-level data and longitudinal follow-ups to determine how much of this difference is due to education, integration and the protection of the most vulnerable minors.

Help Infovaticana continue informing