Digital Religion published on November 18, in its Opinion section and signed by José Parrales, a piece titled “The money surrounding Father Olivera Ravasi and the canonical situation of San Elías.” The article combines two distinct issues. On one hand, there is the decree from the Dicastery for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, dated August 31, which declares that the Order of Saint Elias lacks canonical existence. On the other, a review of tax, commercial, and trademark records of civil entities linked to the Argentine priest.
The author’s own conclusion contradicts the headline’s premise. In his final paragraphs, he admits that on the economic level “there is no evidence of irregularities.” What he offers are questions, missing data presented as indications, and accounts about donors that, as the text itself acknowledges, are not supported by any public document.
A decree on legal status, not a sanction
According to the statement released by the diocese of Fréjus-Toulon on October 8, the Dicastery considers that the letter of approval signed by the bishop of Darjeeling (India) on February 3, 2016, did not constitute a formal erection. From this it concludes that two other acts also had no effect: the reception of the mother house in Ollioules by Bishop Dominique Rey that same year, and the decree by which the archdiocese of Portoviejo (Ecuador) approved the community as a society of apostolic life in 2021.
The document imposes no penalties, suspends no one, and contains no doctrinal reproach. It is limited to the community’s legal status. No priest loses his status or faculties because a society was not validly erected. Canon 265 of the Code of Canon Law requires every cleric to be incardinated. Therefore, if the institute does not exist juridically, its priests remain linked to the diocese in which they are incardinated and exercise ministry with the permission of the corresponding bishops, like any other presbyter.
The decision fits within the tightening of requirements for founding new communities. Since November 2020, following the reform of canon 579 by the motu proprio Authenticum charismatis, the diocesan bishop needs written permission from the Holy See to erect an institute of consecrated life. Canon 732 extends that requirement to societies of apostolic life. The Portoviejo decree is from September 2021. Father Olivera Ravasi has explained that, under the norms approved in recent years, the designation given by the bishops to the community “did not correspond,” and that the decision has been accepted “without problem.”
The origin of the Roman procedure is recorded in a letter from the Dicastery dated November 26, 2024, signed by its undersecretary, Father Aitor Jiménez Echave. The letter is circulating on social media and responds to a query from the archdiocese of Atlanta regarding collections carried out by members of the group in that territory. In it, the Dicastery states that it has no information about the community beyond some recent news. It also announces that it has requested data from the bishops of the dioceses where its members have worked and explains that its goal is to form a precise idea of the group and its “legal nature.” The letter contains no accusation. What Rome examined for nearly two years was the community’s canonical status, and that is what the August decree is limited to. The Dicastery’s lack of knowledge about the group’s existence is consistent, moreover, with the priest’s own explanation: the Portoviejo approval did not go through the Roman permission required by the new norms.
Digital Religion claims that for years donations were requested in the name of an order that the Church never erected. That reading projects a 2026 decision backward. During that time the community had acts signed by three different bishops, and that is how ecclesiastical institutions presented it. The Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe in La Crosse, for example, described it in 2025 as a society of apostolic life of diocesan right of the archdiocese of Portoviejo. If those episcopal acts proved insufficient, the insufficiency lies in them. The diocesan statement does not attribute bad faith or concealment to the priests.
2024 suspicions without a new document
Much of the economic section is not new. The following elements already appeared in an investigation by Ivy Cángaro and Mauro Federico published in September 2024 by Data Clave and reproduced by El Cohete a la Luna:
- the society Order of Saint Elijah, Inc., registered in Georgia in June 2020;
- Palupa Properties LLC, in Florida;
- the tax registration of the Fundación San Elías;
- the Omnes Gentes project;
- the question about the origin of the donations.
That work described Georgia as a tax haven, an extreme that Digital Religion now corrects. Nor then were donation records, transfers, or donor lists provided, and the authors themselves admitted they did not know where the money came from. Two years later, the questions are repeated without a single piece of added evidence.
The rest of the reasoning follows the same pattern. The foundation was registered as an employer in September 2026, and from that fact the author moves on to wonder who worked before and under what conditions, although he acknowledges there is no documentation either way. The QNTLC trademark is registered in the name of the priest who created and directs the channel, and the article does not present it as illegal, but as a striking fact. Nor is it an irregularity that a civil legal entity with the community’s name exists in the United States. Apostolic works routinely use civil foundations and associations to receive donations and administer assets, and the text itself admits that what matters is not the existence of those societies.
More serious is the inclusion of accounts about contributions from businessmen in the Zárate area and a possible link between donations and campaigns in favor of those convicted of crimes against humanity. The author warns that they should be treated as hypotheses to be verified, but publishes them anyway, associated with the name of a specific priest and under a headline that revolves around money.
Neither expelled nor sanctioned
The profile drawn by Digital Religion recalls that in August 2024 the diocese of Zárate-Campana withdrew Father Olivera Ravasi’s authorization to reside in the diocese. The decision came after the controversy over his role in the visit of several deputies to military personnel convicted in the Ezeiza prison. The article also links its own pieces that spoke of “expulsion” and “vagrant priest.” Days later, the spokesperson for the diocese of San Rafael, the diocese of the priest’s incardination, told Diario San Rafael that he had not been expelled or sanctioned. The spokesperson, Father José Antonio Álvarez, spoke of an irregular situation due to the expiration of his leave of absence and specified that this did not constitute a crime.
Since April 2025, Father Olivera Ravasi has lived in the United States. The Star of the Sea parish in San Francisco includes him in its bulletin as parochial vicar. According to canon 547, that office is conferred by the diocesan bishop, in this case Archbishop Salvatore Cordileone, and the appointment presupposes that the archbishop considers him fit for ministry in his archdiocese. Since August 2025 he has also been part-time chaplain for Hispanic pilgrims at the Shrine of Guadalupe in La Crosse, a position he assumed with the blessing of Cardinal Raymond Burke.
On the same November 18, Father Tomás Beroch released a video to support a collection by Father José Ansaldi, who leads the community. The collection seeks to buy a backhoe to serve rural areas of Manabí isolated by rains. In the video, Beroch addressed those on social media who accuse these priests of acting “illegally” or compare them to excommunicated clerics. His argument coincides with what the Code provides: even if the community’s legal status lapses, its priests remain incardinated in their dioceses and may continue their apostolate with the permission of their bishops.
The Digital Religion article does not include Father Olivera Ravasi’s response. The priest has stated that the community accepts the Roman decision and continues its mission “under the authority of various bishops,” now with “a new, more humble canonical designation.” He closes his message with a “Long live the mission!”