The Civic Platform of Christian Families has sent a letter to the Bishop of the Canary Islands, José Mazuelos, asking him to comment on the electoral appeal issued by six Catholic Action movements in his diocese. The text, released ahead of the general elections on November 29, was published as news on the diocesan website. The organization wants the prelate to clarify the canonical status of these groups, whether they have the necessary ecclesiastical consent to present themselves as Catholic, and whether their statement respects the political pluralism of the faithful. The initiative was announced in a note dated November 18 and signed by the president of the Platform, Domingo Pisaca Gámez.
The appeal is endorsed by the Hermandad Obrera de Acción Católica (HOAC), the Juventud Obrera Cristiana (JOC), the Movimiento Junior, the Fraternidad Cristiana de Personas con Discapacidad (Fráter), Profesionales Cristianos, and Acción Católica General. Its date is November 10; the place, Las Palmas de Gran Canaria. Two days later, the diocese’s official website featured it in its news section, with a headline presenting it as a voting suggestion for the most solidarity-oriented candidacies and an introduction stating that the six groups “rule out parties that reject and do not welcome migrants.” The news remained online on November 19, and the Bishop’s Office has not added any clarification.
The appeal proposes as voting criteria solidarity with the poor, the unemployed, precarious workers, and migrants, as well as the recent record of each party. It places farther from the Gospel and the Social Doctrine of the Church those parties that exclude immigrants or foster hatred and racism, and from this it concludes that a Christian’s vote should not go to anyone who promotes discrimination. No party acronym appears in the text; the right and the far right do, as responsible for the denial of male violence. Its paragraphs make no mention of abortion, euthanasia, the family, freedom of education, or religious freedom.
That selection is what the Platform disputes. Its statement does not deny any Catholic the right to engage in politics or to defend the social or economic program they prefer; what it maintains is that the name “Catholic” obliges one to the whole doctrine and that no one may dress up a party preference as the position of the faithful. And the doctrine, it recalls, includes the defense of life from conception to natural death, the family, religious freedom, and the right of parents to educate their children—not only a particular reading of social justice, immigration, or the economy.
Hence what it asks of Mazuelos: to assess whether the appeal respects the legitimate political plurality of Catholics, to have the movements explain what they hold regarding abortion and the rest of Catholic morality, and to expressly recognize that a faithful person may choose between different political options while respecting the fundamental principles of the faith. In the event that he finds actions contrary to the integrity of the faith or to ecclesiastical discipline, it calls for the measures provided for in Canon Law.
“Catholic identity implies a responsibility,” the letter states according to the note, which rejects using the name at convenience: displaying it when it is advantageous and setting it aside when the Church’s teaching clashes with one’s own ideology. The organization makes clear that it does not question the social commitment of the movements or their right to intervene in public life, but rather that someone should claim exclusively the voice of Catholics in an election or present their preferences as a mandate of the Church.
The note does not detail the canons invoked by the letter. The Code of Canon Law prohibits the use of the name “Catholic” for any initiative or association that lacks the consent of the competent authority (canons 216 and 300) and places all associations of the faithful under the vigilance of that authority, with the task of safeguarding the integrity of faith and morals (canon 305). Canon 227 recognizes the laity’s freedom in temporal affairs and requires them not to “present their own opinion as the doctrine of the Church in matters open to debate.” Acción Católica General, one of the six signatories, obtained the approval of its statutes from the Episcopal Conference in 2009.
The letter arrives in the week when the Plenary Assembly of the Episcopal Conference, meeting in Madrid until Friday the 20th, failed to reach the two-thirds majority needed to approve a statement ahead of the 29N, according to InfoVaticana citing sources from the Assembly itself. The Platform signs its note in Tenerife, and the island belongs to the diocese of San Cristóbal de La Laguna, not to that of the Canary Islands. This is not its first intervention in ecclesial matters: in 2016 it supported the then bishop of Nivaria, Bernardo Álvarez, when he banned a Masonic event in a church in Santa Cruz de La Palma. It now hopes that the Bishop’s Office of the Canary Islands will examine the issues raised and issue a response that clearly states the position of the diocesan authority.
Read also