Criticism of Montse Alvarado for saying that the Dicastery for Communication must "communicate Christ to the world"

An Italian commentator claims that the new prefect's mission is limited to informing the media about the Pope, while JD Flynn and Rorate Caeli defend her with Praedicate Evangelium.

Criticism of Montse Alvarado for saying that the Dicastery for Communication must "communicate Christ to the world"
Screenshot

The statement by Montse Alvarado that the mission of the Dicasterio para la Comunicación consists of “communicating Christ to the world” has drawn criticism from Italian commentators, who deny it that function. One of them, in a message posted on the social network X, claims that this “is not true,” that it is done by the baptized animated by the bishops, and that the prefect’s task is “entirely and solely to guarantee information about the Pope to the media.” And he concludes: “She will learn.”

Alvarado assumed the prefecture on November 1, replacing Paolo Ruffini, and is the first laywoman not a religious to head a dicastery. The formula that sparked the controversy is not new: it already appeared in her first statement after the appointment, in which she said she hoped the dicastery would serve the Church “to communicate Christ to the world,” and she repeated it in an interview given to EWTN News In Depth, where she stated that this is the mandate of the body and that she will carry it forward in harmony with the Holy Father.

Flynn: “It is a rather strange ecclesiology”

The most articulated reply has come from American journalist JD Flynn, who responded on X that the criticism “is false” and gave three reasons. The first is that articles 183 to 188 of the apostolic constitution Praedicate Evangelium, which regulates the Roman Curia, describe for the dicastery a role broader than that of “running a press office.” The second is that the mission of the Curia is that of the Gospel, which consists precisely in the communication of Christ. The third, that his opponent’s thesis reflects “a basically strange ecclesiology.”

Flynn also wrote, in another message, that Italians will find it hard to understand an American Catholic who sees her work as a missionary apostolate and whose declared desire is not “neutral professional competence” but a “contagious Christian enthusiasm.”

Defense on social media: “The Pope chose her”

The CatholicSat profile has also joined in defending the prefect. Its message notes that she has been in the post for a couple of days and that “a group of Italian men” are condescendingly explaining to her that she does not understand her job, and concludes that Alvarado already shows why she was “a fantastic choice” to lead Vatican communications.

For its part, Rorate Caeli reproduces the Italian comment and speaks of “indignation” from left-wing sectors at the new head. It stresses that it was the Pope who chose her and that, “presumably, he knows what he is doing.”

A debut that had already drawn attention

Alvarado made her debut before the accredited press on November 4, with the briefing on Pope Leo XIV’s trip to Uruguay, Argentina and Peru, where she assured that she trusts in the Pope’s health. Her profile, coming from EWTN News and the Becket Fund, contrasts with that of her predecessor, who had led the dicastery since 2018, and what is now being discussed in the press and on social media is how far the mandate of an organism extends whose constitution, according to its defenders, goes beyond mere press information.

Help Infovaticana continue informing