Women, men and feminism

Women, men and feminism
<strong>Helen Andrews</strong>

By Francis X. Maier

NOTE: We’ve reached the end of another week, and I’m grateful for the generosity readers have shown. But this still won’t work unless many more of you step forward. And soon. It really isn’t right to make me beg, is it? Be merciful and quick to support TCT. Today. – Robert Royal

The Book of Proverbs contains two verses—31:26 and 28—that gladden the heart of any man wise enough to marry a woman of deep Christian character: “She opens her mouth with wisdom, and the teaching of kindness is on her tongue… Her children rise up and call her blessed; her husband also, and he praises her.”

My life is filled with women I love: a beautiful wife (and veteran educator) of 56 years; a wonderful daughter, mother of seven; two daughters-in-law, each a successful executive; and six granddaughters. Together they shape my world. Their happiness matters to me. So it seems reasonable to ask whether modern feminism serves that goal, and how.

Opinions are divided.

We might begin with this quote: “The rule of law will not survive the legal profession becoming majority female.” Those are incendiary words. They’re meant to sting. But they’re not the bile of some misogynist male. They come from “The Great Feminization,” an October 2025 essay by Helen Andrews, drawn from a talk she gave at a conference a month earlier. The video of that talk has so far racked up 373,000 views. Online, her essay has millions more. In short, it struck a nerve.

Andrews is an author of notable intellect and talent. She’s willing to make people uncomfortable when it comes to matters of substance, and she points out that women are increasingly occupying the leading institutions of our society—medicine, business, journalism, and law. And as they become the majority, those institutions change, sometimes for the better and sometimes not.

Why? Because women differ from men in how they think, act, and exercise power. “Cancel culture,” she argues, “is simply what women do whenever there are enough of them in a given organization or field… Everything you think of as ‘wokeness’ is simply an epiphenomenon of demographic feminization.”

Philosopher Carrie Gress takes a different but equally critical approach to feminism in her books The End of Woman and Something Wicked. She notes—as James Billington did in his classic study of the revolutionary spirit, Fire in the Minds of Men—that prominent early feminists flirted with or actively practiced the occult. They despised Christianity and saw the family as a trap of female servitude. For Gress, then, modern feminism is poisoned at the root. In practice, it functions as a shadow anti-church. It cannot be purified or “baptized.”

Gress is a gifted and eloquent scholar, as this and this demonstrate. She keenly understands the costs that mainstream feminism has imposed on women. The movement’s “sacrament” of abortion, for example, is at once an act of self-harm and a license to kill millions of unborn children. Thus, in Something Wicked, she argues that “Christianity, at its core, is built on the richness of relationships, family, and tradition. Feminism was built on an ideological system that denies the goodness of all three. The two simply cannot mix.”

Carrie Gress

Unfortunately, the problem with a word like “feminism” is twofold. First, as with “socialism,” “liberalism,” or even “Christianity,” different people use the same word to mean very different things. Second, all enduring ideas—even the worst ones—have some seed of truth that sustains them. Mainstream modern feminism, for all its flaws, is the flower of a legitimate grievance: the experience of mistreatment and discrimination women have endured for centuries. So the question becomes: in the world as it is, how should Christians respond?

In recent decades, organizations like ENDOW—“Educating on the Nature and Dignity of Women”—have reached hundreds of thousands of women with a biblical vision of female dignity and leadership. It’s a vision accessed through St. John Paul II’s letter on women, Mulieris Dignitatem.

Author Terry Polakovic, ENDOW’s co-founder and first president, calmly describes herself as a “feminist” of the pro-life Christian tribe. And she is far from alone. Dozens of similar Christian apostolates today seek to serve women by applying Scripture to the demands of their daily lives. In doing so, at their best, they elevate feminism’s seed of truth to the fullness of its biblical dignity and purpose.

As for prominent Catholic scholars and leaders, think of Helen Alvaré, Anna Moreland, Abigail Favale, Noelle Mering, Margarita Mooney Clayton, Mary Hasson, Theresa Farnan—the list is long. Leah Libresco Sargeant’s recent book, The Dignity of Dependence: A Feminist Manifesto, reviewed here, is also worth noting.

Note, too, the work of Erika Bachiochi. Like the daughter I mentioned earlier, Bachiochi is a wife and mother of seven. She is also a distinguished legal scholar and author of The Rights of Women: Reclaiming a Lost Vision. Her interview with the Napa Institute a few years ago can be viewed here.

The good news is this: all the women mentioned embody an authentic Christian “feminism,” rooted in complementarity rather than hostility between men and women.

The other news—and I suppose it’s simply a warning—is this: Helen Andrews, whose essay I cited earlier, also said this: “I am the mother of boys, who will never reach their full potential if they have to grow up in a feminized world.”

I began this column with a concern for the women in my life. But I have another reason: five young grandsons. Earlier this year, the Institute for Family Studies released America’s Demoralized Men, a two-part study available here and here. It’s essential reading. Most of the 2,000 young men aged 18 to 29 surveyed by the IFS study still want the right things: marriage, family, and productive work. Most understand that sacrifice is required to reach those goals. But they feel isolated, unsure of their own worth and purpose, and scolded by a society that disdains manhood.

Rootless, unhappy men do not end well. If we want even more Lost Boys, drones, and predators in our world than we already have, we need only keep doing what we’re doing. The bitter irony is that today’s feminism has helped create too many men no sensible woman would want. And that serves no one.

About the Author

Francis X. Maier is a senior fellow in Catholic studies at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. He is the author of True Confessions: Voices of Faith from a Life in the Church.

Help Infovaticana continue informing