I was reading the final pages of “The Camp of the Saints,” by Jean Raspail, when I came across the news that the French writer Michel Houellebecq is also facing trial for hate speech in connection with his book “Submission,” published in 2015.
So I reread “Submission,” a novel that imagines a France in which an Islamist party, the Muslim Brotherhood, reaches the presidency of the government in 2017 with the votes of socialists and centrists, willing to do anything to stop the “far right” represented by the National Front. What follows is the total transformation of the country to the norms of sharia, Islamic law. And what is disturbing is that this does not lead to any revolution by the French, but rather that France capitulates.
It turns out—as Guadalupe Sánchez explained in The Objective on the 13th—that “11 years later, reality has decided to imitate fiction in the most grotesque way: through the courts. Last Tuesday, an investigating judge in Nanterre charged Houellebecq with ‘complicity in incitement to discrimination, hatred, or violence,’ following a complaint filed in January 2023 by the Union of Mosques of France over statements he made in the magazine Front Populaire. There he predicted a ‘reverse Bataclan’ and claimed that what many French people wanted from Muslims was not that they assimilate, but that they stop robbing and assaulting them. Or that they leave. One can agree with these words or be radically opposed to them. But putting the novelist on trial for his opinions is exactly what Submission described: a society on which silence is imposed as a prelude to capitulation. Punitive punishment as a tool to muzzle dissent and impose surrender.”
“Who are we supposed to surrender to?” the journalist asks.
Let us try to explain by returning to the prophetic novel we cited at the beginning, “The Camp of the Saints,” by Jean Raspail, first published in 1973. In a France already in the 1970s with a significant Muslim presence, the result of decolonization, a continuous influx of people from West and North Africa and the reproduction of their way of life on French soil, with no intention of adapting to or respecting any Western customs, the novel recounts the arrival of a million destitute people from India in a fleet of dilapidated ships on the coasts of France and the reaction of various segments of French society before the landing.
Raspail, a (traditional) Catholic and monarchist, reflects something we see perfectly turned into reality today: a wave of naive do-goodism and political correctness that, together with the paradoxical alliance of the progressive left (and today, woke) with Islam, leads to capitulation, to the surrender of Europe, to the suicidal opening toward a “new multicultural society” that would end “the white privilege that has caused the misery of the third world.” That terrible Western, European self-hatred that Benedict XVI spoke so clearly about.
Curiously—or not—both books are set in France, since, like the United Kingdom with its Commonwealth, they have been recipients of massive immigration from their former colonies for six decades, which has brought about profound social changes. In England there are already dozens of Muslim mayors. In Paris, third-generation Muslims practice endogamy to continue preserving their way of life, while reproducing at a rate at least five times higher than native French people. But these realities are already massively present in many other European places, even though the phenomenon is more recent: Belgium is full of no-go zones, the Scandinavian countries and their reception policies have had disastrous results, and even in the United States Islam is advancing politically. The mayor of New York is Muslim—and socialist!
Guadalupe Sánchez points out in her article in The Objective that “Muslims in Spain already number about two and a half million, around 5% of the population, according to the Union of Islamic Communities itself. And the CEU-CEFAS Demographic Observatory, in its report Demography of Islam in Spain, notes that their crime rates are, in aggregate terms, above those of the rest of the population. The same observatory had already warned in a previous report that the criminality of African immigrants is much higher than that of Spaniards in the crimes that cause the most harm to people. And those who pay that bill are, above all, women (…). The worst part is that we have become accustomed to it. Nice, Barcelona, Arras, Solingen, Mannheim. The priest Jacques Hamel, beheaded by a Muslim while celebrating Holy Mass. The sacristan Diego Valencia, murdered with machetes in Algeciras. The Western response is also always the same: candles, teddy bears, Imagine and a generic condemnation of violence. And waiting for the next one. And if not, he was unbalanced. He always is. From certain political pulpits, moreover, they explain to us that the problem is ours, stirring up xenophobia and racism, while keeping the doors open. Do-goodism does not let us see that uncontrolled irregular immigration has also become a weapon of war.”
I imagine you have heard of the Kalergi Plan. Google defines it as “a racist and supremacist conspiracy theory that claims there is a secret plan by the elites to promote massive non-white immigration to Europe in order to mix the population, destroy European identity and replace it.” Can anyone seriously think that this is just a “racist conspiracy theory”? Whoever promotes it, it is obvious that there is a strategy to make Europe disappear as we know it, with the complicity—worse still, with the initiative—of European rulers themselves. Let us look at the Spanish case: Pedro Sánchez could be accused of treason and of lying in Congress for his role in the invasion of Ceuta by Morocco. The government knew that a number of people equal to the native population was arriving, did not act, let them settle and now intends to distribute them throughout Spain. Men of military age, all of them. It is not racism. According to the RAE, as Lucía Etxebarría states, it is an invasion. It is not a statement that can constitute a hate crime, but a definition of the phenomenon. Afterwards, miscegenation with Western women or family reunification will do the rest to finish third-worldizing Europe.
In an aspect that interests us especially, the role of the Catholic Church in all this, Raspail’s portrait is curious: in the early 1970s, the bishops and priests—and even the pope—who appear in the novel play a role somewhere between useful idiot and total irrelevance, calling for the welcome of all and universal brotherhood. If we look at our current panorama, once again, reality surpasses fiction.
How can we understand the stance of the ecclesiastical hierarchy, of so many priests, of Cáritas, of Manos Unidas (not to mention the Red Cross), when they speak of “migrant brothers” and the supposed benefits of the mass regularization of young Muslim men who are the main ones responsible, relative to their total percentage within the population of our country (as statistical data show), for the increase in street violence, robberies, beatings and sexual abuse of women? How can we understand that the pope went to the Canary Islands and Lampedusa to honor the invaders, that he continually exhorts us to an indiscriminate policy of open doors to Muslims?
It is not understandable. And we are not obliged by obedience to share their opinions which, moreover, and more importantly, do not correspond to the Social Doctrine of the Church.
The French author Julien Langella, in his book “Catholics and Identitarians,” bases himself precisely on what is happening in his country to reflect on the Social Doctrine of the Church. We will rely on some of his ideas, which, being what the Church says, must be the rule of our behavior and attitude toward the Islamic invasion we are suffering. Langella has a clear message based on the Bible and the traditional teachings of the Church: “we must resist, we must fight and we must defend the greatness of our identities because in this lies the survival of the faith in Europe and the very preservation of Christian civilization”.
What does the Church really say? The Church has developed a social doctrine (pp. 159 ff.), a set of political principles derived from faith and the observation of human relations, to help men govern the city (polis) with a view to the common good (Catechism of the Catholic Church, #2423). The Church provides criteria for judgment, gives guidelines for action; it has a point of view on freedom, authority, family, property or work: notions whose interpretation has important consequences in public life. That is why the Church, which seeks nothing more than to push souls toward God, has something to say in the social environment of men. Among the great concerns of Social Doctrine are population movements. The Church does not ignore that immigration can threaten the peace and balance of host societies. Attentive to the growing magnitude of the phenomenon, it formulated clear principles that could serve as a compass. In 1948, Pius XII affirmed that, when a dignified existence is not possible in some countries, “the paths of immigration must be opened” for those forced to leave their home and settle abroad; the principles must be fulfilled that the emigrant is “forced” to leave his country and must at the same time be “needed” in the place of destination, limiting reception to the common good. From here, in the turbulent 1960s, with Paul VI and his apostolic letter Pastoralis migratorum cura of 1969, there was a change of discourse in the social doctrine of the Church, moving from the duty of charity toward the oppressed to the ideological valorization of immigration as something absolute. Does that sound familiar? It is what Julien Langella calls, using words of Dom Gérard, a Benedictine monk founder of Le Barroux, the “globalist heresy,” an attempt to rebuild the Tower of Babel, taking the creature for the Creator, as in every heresy. This dream of Babel, in which the earthly paradise would be reached through the mixing of peoples and races, is profoundly anti-Christian; and it is, moreover, in total contradiction with the habitual teaching of the popes, according to which the duty of hospitality, which derives from charity, is limited by the requirements of the common good.
The statements of John Paul II and Benedict XVI were in the same sense as those of Pius XII, while Francis changed course, perhaps following the wake of Paul VI or guided by his personal convictions from an Ibero-American perspective and the assumption of the Black Legend about the evangelization of America. And Leo follows in Francis’s wake. For Saint John Paul II, the right to emigrate “must be regulated, since its uncontrolled application could be dangerous and harmful to the common good of the communities that welcome migrants”. For Benedict XVI, “States have the right to regulate migratory flows and defend their borders while always guaranteeing respect for the dignity of each human person.” This balance is guaranteed by the agreement between justice and charity: “Whoever loves others with charity is first just toward them,” Benedict XVI reminds us, and “charity demands justice: the recognition and respect of the legitimate rights of individuals and peoples”. Among those rights, undeniably, is the right to live in peace according to one’s own identity, which is possible through the sovereignty of the State, prepared to protect its people. It is this right that is violated with the blind opening of European borders.
The Catechism admits that “political authorities may, with the objective of the common good, subordinate the exercise of the right of immigration to various legal conditions, especially respect for the duties of migrants with respect to their country of adoption. The immigrant is supposed to show respect and recognition toward the material and spiritual heritage of the host country” (#2241). By placing the primacy of the common good and subjecting the reception of immigrants to the free appreciation of sovereign States, the Church recalls that Social Doctrine is not a political program but a set of general guidelines that must be adapted to each particular reality.
In short, appealing to the social doctrine of the Church, but also to common sense, how can it be considered racism or xenophobia, and even a lack of solidarity, to see massive Islamic immigration as a threat to social peace and our Christian-rooted culture? Lukewarmness, the blackmail of social shame, fear of what people will say, of ostracism and other alibis of good conscience lead us to assume positions that have little or nothing to do with the social doctrine of the Church and to be accomplices of this situation that leads us to spiritual and cultural suicide. We Catholics are intoxicated, like the rest of the do-gooder Europeans, with emotional arguments and a sort of preference for foreigners (which also involves hatred of what is our own).
It took an American convert, J.D. Vance, to remind the pope, cardinals, bishops and priests of the order of charity: that is, first, those closest to us. And, lastly, and if it does not affect the common good, those from outside. In this case, ecclesiastical blindness is even more difficult to digest, because it is not only about “migrant” people, but about Muslims who rape European women, impose their barbarism and intend to do away with everyone who is not Muslim. The cases of Fr. Hamel and Diego Valencia do not serve them as a lesson. Nor do the attacks in Barcelona or in the Christmas markets in Germany. They do not understand that, as soon as the favorable occasion arises, the first ones to be put to the knife will be them. And in the meantime, they throw their sheep to the wolves.