The Archbishop of Oviedo, Jesús Sanz Montes, today publishes in the ABC op-ed section, eight days before the general elections on November 29, an article titled “Is there a Catholic vote?” His answer is that there is not, “although there are Catholics who are going to vote,” and his conclusion addresses the nature of the change decided at the ballot box: “An alternation is not enough, but a real alternative without hollow or sluggish words that end up leaving things as they are behind the same obscene scenery.”
The prelate lists the issues that, in his view, should weigh on the conscience of the Christian voter: lies in public life, abortion and euthanasia, the manipulation of male and female identity, laws that “have put terrorists, abusers and rapists on the streets,” corruption and immigration. He also explains that at the recent Plenary Assembly of the Spanish Episcopal Conference the bishops considered issuing a statement ahead of the elections and that “we thought it better” to refer to the address given by Leo XIV before the Cortes Generales on June 8. As InfoVaticana reported, the note presented to the Plenary did not obtain the two-thirds majority required for approval.
We reproduce the full text below.
Is there a Catholic vote?
Jesús Sanz Montes, OFM, Archbishop of Oviedo
When current socio-political events call us to appear in something like general elections, a question that has become familiar to us arises. The premises from which a person takes a stance and coherently exercises their freedom by voting for a political party seem to exclude the possibility that moral conscience, in a Christian key, might also serve as a criterion. For many, this conscience must be censored, as if silence and invisibility were the only permitted ways for us Christians to be present in matters that concern the course of the society of which we are also a part.
But that is not the case; rather, we have the right and the duty to make ourselves present within a plural reality, to share with freedom and respect our point of view in a situation that is not alien to the values we uphold as defining our worldview. We are not appealing to an obsolete theocracy of past times, the kind that still circulates in Islamic countries, but neither do we accept a calculatedly exclusionary censorship that reduces Christians to the catacombs or sacristies, where, if we remain silent and invisible, we might even be subsidized, provided our faith does not express its own culture, nor an ethical judgment, nor show its referential presence.
Having said that, I believe there is no Catholic vote, although there are Catholics who are going to vote. It means we have not delegated our moral conscience to party labels that would politically represent us, even though we know how to recognize the distance that brings us closer to or moves us away from certain electoral premises and their management of public affairs when they exercise governance. When we point out a political, social and cultural scenario as inadequate or desire it as desirable, our point of view takes as its reference biblical wisdom, the example of Jesus of Nazareth, the Christian tradition forged in the saints, and the social doctrine of the Church. It is an outlook always in a moral key, not a political one.
At the recent Plenary Assembly of the Spanish Episcopal Conference, we considered the possibility of issuing a brief statement regarding this electoral call, addressed to the Christian community and to all who might be interested in knowing our ecclesial perspective, without replacing the freedom of those who, in conscience, responsibly exercise their right to vote. However, we thought it better to propose the reading of the address that Leo XIV delivered before the Cortes Generales. It is the best synthesis of what our Christian conscience represents with its political consequences, our way of building the “polis,” the city, together with others who also do so from a specific political formation. It is worth rereading the papal address, so applauded by the entire chamber of senators and deputies and by society as a whole in that memorable intervention of the Holy Father in the seat of national sovereignty. There appear the better horizons to which we should aspire and the red lines to avoid, when the dignity of the person, life in all its phases, family and education, freedom and coexistence draw, without polarization, a serene and just society. In this way, various themes emerge that I now wish to highlight.
First, the value of truth. Not a demagogic truth with traps to deceive at will, but the humble truth that sets us free, as Jesus said. We are critical of those who knowingly lie in their unfulfilled promises, deceitfully, beguiling with ingenuousness those who trust them. The string of lies we have seen in these years strips all credibility from the mendacious lips that proclaim them without blushing, and makes it impossible to support the tricks of the professional con artists who have landed in politics, as we have verified so many times.
Also, the ideological agendas that have sown confusion and lethal destruction when we speak of nascent, growing and waning life, imposing the cheapened absurdity of abortion as a right or subsidized euthanasia as a butcher’s shove. Precarious life without finding housing or work, barely making it to the end of the month stitched together with debts. The manipulation of male and female identity in an insidious confrontation. Laws that have put terrorists, abusers and rapists on the streets, or that have destroyed anthropological truth regarding gender dysphoria. Playing God in this way ruins so many innocent lives in the name of the fantasies or frustrations of those who promote them, whose consequences, unfortunately, have no turning back.
No less significant is the systemic corruption in some parties, where the triad denounced by T.S. Eliot holds sway: power, money and lust, with whose frivolous misdeeds they steal for personal gain and to keep their labels in office, with enormous consequences for the security of our borders and our road communications. There are corruptions that kill with an obscene forgetting or manipulation of the victims.
For five centuries we have belonged to a historical community, Spain, enriching ourselves in plural diversity, with some cultural and linguistic tensions. We discovered new worlds and others discover us when their emigrants reach us with mutual benefit if we approach it rightly, without terrorists and criminals involved in human trafficking or blood crimes invading us. Upsetting coexistence with malice yields rich profits for its instigators who live off it and encourages a subversive imposture that harms our fraternal understanding and mutual solidarity.
I have a doubt in my civic conscience and my Christian moral reference. Before a new government, are we speaking of an alternation or an alternative? Coming to the same thing, but managed by other managers, would have regrettable consequences in a nation like Spain, with the precious cultural and moral heritage of its historical journey. An alternation is not enough, but a real alternative without hollow or sluggish words that end up leaving things as they are behind the same obscene scenery.
Yes, there is a Christian worldview of history, our own way of building the city within a plural scenario. We do not want to be used by anyone, but to contribute our legitimate collaboration alongside those we recognize as closer. In the ballot box will be life, truth, coexistence, justice, honesty and freedom. Spain will be there. We must also vote responsibly as Christians.
Read also