The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) approved on November 18, by 205 votes in favor and none against or abstentions, to begin the review of the Pastoral Plan for Pro-Life Activities, which was last updated in 2001. The vote took place at the fall plenary assembly that the bishops are holding in Baltimore from November 16 to 19. The agreement authorizes the Secretariat for Pro-Life Activities to review and update the document.
It was Bishop Daniel Thomas of Toledo (Ohio) and chairman of the USCCB pro-life committee who asked his brothers for permission to begin the process. Thomas explained that the plan, used by the conference’s pro-life office, many diocesan offices, and numerous parishes, had become outdated following the Dobbs decision, which overturned Roe v. Wade. The 2001 text frequently refers to Roe as the law of the land, something that no longer reflects legal reality.
Medication abortion, assisted suicide, and in vitro fertilization
The chairman of the pro-life committee listed other changes since 2001 that, in his view, require an update. According to him, the number of abortions is rising, abortion pills are within everyone’s reach, and several states are legalizing abortion. He added that thirteen states already permit assisted suicide and that others are preparing to follow them, and that in vitro fertilization and other assisted reproductive techniques have become widespread.
Thomas also recalled that since the last edition there have been several pontificates—those of Benedict XVI, Francis, and Leo XIV—and that the new plan must incorporate their teaching on life, including that related to the death penalty and the end of life. The four major areas of the document—namely, public information and education, pastoral care, action in the field of public policy, and prayer and worship—will be maintained.
The nuncio calls for the inclusion of surrogacy
During the debate, the apostolic nuncio to the United States, Archbishop Gabriele Caccia, intervened and requested that the revised plan include advocacy for a ban on surrogacy. He described it as a new form of human trafficking worldwide and as “another frontier” for the pro-life movement. The nuncio said he was not sure whether it was appropriate for him to comment, as he is not a voting member of the USCCB, and he supported the start of the review.
The vote only opens the process: the Secretariat for Pro-Life Activities must now draft the new text, and no timeline has been announced for its final approval. The plan, first approved in 1975 and renewed in 1985 and 2001, remains the conference’s reference for its work in defense of life.
The decision comes at the same assembly in which the prelates have stated that they will work with Trump and the Democratic Congress.