Strickland asks bishops to restore communion rails and Communion on the knees and on the tongue

Bishop Joseph Strickland, removed from the Diocese of Tyler (Texas) in 2023, has urged U.S. bishops to bring back altar rails, to receive Communion kneeling and on the tongue, and to eliminate extraordinary ministers. He makes this proposal following a recent study showing that only 29% of Catholics in the United States believe in the real presence.

Strickland asks bishops to restore communion rails and Communion on the knees and on the tongue
Joseph Strickland, obispo de Tyler

Bishop Joseph Strickland has recorded a podcast aimed primarily at his brother bishops in the United States. In it, he calls for restoring reverence toward the Eucharist through concrete measures: reinstalling communion rails in churches, encouraging the faithful to receive Communion kneeling and on the tongue, eliminating extraordinary ministers, and facilitating access to the Traditional Mass. LifeSiteNews published the transcript, and the Polish portal PCh24 has echoed it.

Strickland, whom Pope Francis removed from the governance of the Diocese of Tyler in November 2023, begins with the words of institution: “This is my body.” He recalls that when Christ declared that His flesh is true food and His blood true drink, many of those listening departed. The Lord did not attempt to retain them by clarifying that He was speaking symbolically. His teaching was hard, but it was true.

A revival that does not move the numbers

The prelate bases his diagnosis on a recent study showing that only 29% of U.S. Catholics believe that Jesus Christ is truly present under the Eucharistic species. The figure is largely explained by those who never or almost never attend Mass, but Strickland emphasizes that the problem also affects regular churchgoers. Among those who attend every week, belief in the Real Presence hovers around 60%. In other words, roughly four out of ten faithful who go to Mass every week do not profess it.

The bishop acknowledges that the National Eucharistic Revival of recent years has helped many people, but notes that the statistics do not reflect it: the proportion of Catholics who believe in the Eucharist has not increased.

Part of the explanation, in his view, lies in the fact that dioceses have been operating like corporations. He admits that a diocese has employees, legal and financial obligations, and investments, and that a bishop cannot handle all of this alone. Nevertheless, his task is to be a shepherd and to proclaim the apostolic faith. “A bishop should ask himself whether the children of his diocese believe in the consecration. He should ask himself whether his priests clearly proclaim this truth, whether Catholics understand what it means to receive the Eucharist worthily, and whether the worship in his churches is filled with adoration,” he stated.

What is taught without words

For Strickland, the way the Eucharist is treated during Mass is itself a form of catechesis. “What does a child learn by watching the adults around him during Mass?” he asked. And also what a seminarian learns from the way a priest approaches the tabernacle, and what is communicated through silence, kneeling, contact with the Host, and the manner of receiving Communion.

A child who sees his father kneeling before the Blessed Sacrament receives a lesson in faith even if he cannot yet express it in words, he explained. Likewise, when the faithful see the priest carefully handling even the smallest particles of the Host, they learn the faith of the Church. And when the Eucharist is treated lightly, a lesson is also conveyed.

The bishop largely attributes the weakening of the sense of the sacred to the liturgical changes that followed the Second Vatican Council: the removal of communion rails, Communion in the hand, and the habitual use of extraordinary ministers.

Communion rails, kneeling, and an end to extraordinary ministers

“I believe we should restore communion rails and actively encourage those who are physically able to receive Holy Communion kneeling and on the tongue. Kneeling expresses adoration with the whole body,” Strickland maintained, seeing the communion rail as a place to kneel and observe a moment of silence before the Lord. Those who cannot kneel, he added, should be helped to express their reverence according to their abilities: “The goal is to cultivate adoration.”

He also proposes abandoning the use of extraordinary ministers of Holy Communion. He acknowledges that many laypeople exercise this ministry out of sincere love for Christ, but believes that the current practice does not help people perceive the sacredness of the sacrament.

These are pastoral proposals from a bishop who currently governs no diocese, not disciplinary norms. In the United States, the norm approved by the Episcopal Conference with the approval of the Holy See is to receive Communion standing, although each faithful may do so kneeling. The instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum (2004) establishes that Communion may not be denied to anyone who kneels and that every faithful always has the right to receive it on the tongue. The Code of Canon Law, for its part, reserves the extraordinary ministry to cases where necessity advises it (cc. 230 §3 and 910 §2). The issue is current in the country: as of January 16, 2026, the Bishop of Charlotte, Michael Martin, prohibits the use of communion rails and kneelers for receiving Communion at public Masses in his diocese.

Strickland’s final proposal is to expand access to the Traditional Mass, which he sees as a way to renew Eucharistic faith. He notes that the Novus Ordo Mass can be celebrated “with deep reverence, and many Catholics have encountered Our Lord through it,” but he desires that the Church embrace its own spiritual richness and continue its liturgical tradition.

“The revival of the Eucharist must reach the altar and remain there. For this to happen, we must once again understand that the Holy Mass is a sacrifice. The Mass must lead us to prostrate ourselves,” he concluded.

Help Infovaticana continue informing