The bishop of Jundiaí (Brazil), Arnaldo Carvalheiro Neto, states that LGBT+ Catholic groups “can be prophetic signs for the whole Church.” He makes this claim in a text published on November 17 by Outreach, the content platform on LGBT Catholics run by Jesuit James Martin, who presents it as an adapted and condensed version of the address the prelate delivered at the III Regional Meeting of the North and Northeast of the National Network of LGBT+ Catholic Groups, held in Fortaleza (Ceará) from June 4 to 6, under the motto “Tenderness and dignity: pastoral care as an expression of God’s mercy.”
According to the text, these groups “remind us that faith is not the property of those who have never known conflict, but the path of those who allow themselves to be found by Christ.” The bishop adds that the Church must listen to its peripheries and see them not as a threat, but as a place where the Spirit can speak. The article was translated from Portuguese by Jesuit Ricardo da Silva.
Dignity, mercy and conversion
Carvalheiro Neto cites Pope Francis’s exhortation Evangelii gaudium—“no one is excluded from the joy the Lord brings us”—and maintains that dignity is a gift from God and not a concession from the community. He also writes that “a healed community becomes a healing community,” and that those who have been comforted can comfort, those who have been welcomed can welcome, and those who have experienced mercy can become a sign of it.
The bishop further specifies that members of these groups need conversion, like everyone else, and that God’s unconditional love is not a license for a faith without conversion, but the gateway to true conversion. In his view, these people can also help the Church itself to be converted.
A prelate already known for his accompaniment of these groups
The presidency of the National Conference of Bishops of Brazil (CNBB) appointed Carvalheiro Neto on October 17, 2025, as the reference bishop for the pastoral accompaniment of the National Network of LGBT+ Catholic Groups until 2028, according to InfoVaticana reported at the time. He remains at the head of the diocese of Jundiaí, in the state of São Paulo.
In March, the prelate hosted in his episcopal residence the meeting of LGBT+ Catholic groups from the state of São Paulo, which included the celebration of Mass and a dialogue on the role of these collectives in the Church. That gathering already drew criticism because it involved a bishop known for several pastoral controversies in his diocese.
The text has now been shared on the social network X by James Martin himself, who presents it as new and reproduces the passage on the prophetic value of these groups.