By Michael Pakaluk
NOTE: Professor Pakaluk today carefully analyzes—and it was much needed—a piece of bad news about the low levels of faith in the Real Presence of Christ in the Eucharist among Catholics. Things may not be as bad as a recent survey suggested. But Vatican II said that the Eucharist is the “source and summit” of Christian life. So, if Catholics waver regarding that teaching, it may mean that things are truly very precarious. Now we must resort to every available means—teaching, preaching, devotions—to restore that understanding. That is one of our central commitments here at TCT. If that is also important to you, please help us. – Robert Royal
A recent study reports, once again, that only about three out of ten American Catholics believe in the Real Presence. Suppose someone asks you the question posed by the study: “Do you believe that, when the priest consecrates the host during Mass, (1) the bread and wine are transformed and really become the body and blood of Christ, or do you believe that (2) the bread and wine are symbols of his body and blood, or (3) are you unsure of what happens?”
You should answer that this is a deeply confusing question. Any well-instructed Catholic should say that they are not quite sure how to answer it.
Answer (1), as it would be understood in ordinary language, is false. It is not true that the bread and wine are “transformed.” The substance of the bread and the substance of the wine certainly change, but the accidents (the appearances) remain the same. Since the bread and wine are nothing other than the substances together with their accidents, they are not transformed.
Even if answer (1) were corrected in that sense, it would still be misleading, because it is incomplete. The substance of the bread becomes the body of Christ, yes; but the whole Christ is present in the consecrated bread, his “body, blood, soul, and divinity,” and likewise in the consecrated wine.
Christ is alive, not dead. Therefore, he must have a soul. He is both God and man. Therefore, he must possess divinity. As worded, the question invites us to imagine that the bread becomes the body and the wine the blood, and nothing more, which amounts to imagining Christ as a corpse, because only when he lay in the tomb was his body separated from his blood and his soul.
The question leaves out precisely what makes eucharistic devotion the love of a divine Person.
Faced with these difficulties, a thoughtful person might prefer answer (2), because it is true that “when” the priest consecrates the host, just as “before” doing so, the bread and wine are symbols of the body and blood of Christ (that is, they represent them). Answer (2), then, seems more truthful than (1). Note that answer (2) does not refer to what happens after the consecration or by it. In particular, it does not claim that the bread and wine remain unchanged, nor that they are “mere” symbols. A sacrament effects what it symbolizes: of course they are symbols.
Thus, anyone who thought carefully about answers (1) and (2) might feel compelled to choose (3) as the safe option, so that “I am unsure of what happens” would come to mean “I am unsure whether I can endorse either of the two alternatives you offer me.” After all, a faithful Catholic may freely choose (3) if by that they mean: “I am unsure of the mechanism or the means by which it happens,” that is, “it is a mystery.”
Are you really “sure of what happens” at the moment of consecration?
Should we consider it a worthwhile goal that everyone who checks a box identifying as “Catholic” also answers option (1) to the previous question? I do not see that it is. Is it a great failure if someone does not? The greater failure is that most of those Catholics rarely go to Mass. And yet, what is lamented is the checkbox when it is reported that only one-third of Catholics believe in the Real Presence.
The goal seems even stranger when the question appears in a series of surveys that also asks: “Do you agree or disagree that it is sometimes all right for a married person to have sexual relations with someone other than his or her spouse?” (in the 2014 edition, only 74 percent disagreed), and “Approximately how many times did you have sexual relations in the last 2 weeks?”
The study was limited to surveying about 1,000 self-identified Catholics. It did not ask anything that would measure exposure, such as: “Did you attend any eucharistic procession or devotion in your parish?” A natural experiment remains to be done: to see whether Catholics who lived along the route of a procession came to believe or practice more firmly than comparable Catholics elsewhere.
The authors of the study state that “a new set of data on American Catholics indicates once again that faith in the Real Presence hovers around three out of ten.” They lament that “the Church’s important efforts to teach the Real Presence… do not appear to have generated any broad, detectable movement toward faith in Christ in the Eucharist when measured on a national scale.”
In a footnote to that lament, the authors cite Fr. Peter Stravinskas, who describes the National Eucharistic Revival as “a well-intentioned project that, in my opinion, has not gone anywhere,” and adds: “If the promoters of the Revival think that organizing processions across the country is going to change things, they are very mistaken.”
For my part, I believe that any sincere act of eucharistic piety will have powerful effects on souls, with graces pouring forth like rays from a central light, even if they may not bear visible fruit for years. It seems impossible to me that it “has not gone anywhere.”
Nevertheless, I would insist that eucharistic piety must be taught throughout the Church in the way it is successfully taught within families, and that our efforts to revive it should focus on Catholics who already attend Mass every week (of whom, in fact, about 60 percent answer option (1)), rather than on all those who call themselves “Catholics.”
But how is eucharistic piety successfully taught within families? First, by using a simple formula and repeating it often, such as: “Jesus Christ is truly present in the Eucharist, in body, blood, soul, and divinity.”
Second, by asking people to behave before the Eucharist as they would before God incarnate; for example, knowing where to look when they genuflect upon entering a church, and dressing at least as well as they would for a country club or a job interview.
Third, by allowing and encouraging postures of adoration, such as receiving Communion on one’s knees.
Catholics formed in this way may guess how they are “supposed” to answer a survey, however poorly worded. And, more importantly, they will adore the “hidden Divinity here.”
About the author
Michael Pakaluk, a specialist in Aristotle and ordinary academician of the Pontifical Academy of St. Thomas Aquinas, is professor of Political Economy at the Busch School of Business of The Catholic University of America, distinguished senior fellow of the Gibbons Institute, and editor of the American Catholic Quarterly Review. He lives in Hyattsville, Maryland, with his wife, Catherine, also a professor at the Busch School, and their children. His most recent book, on natural law and civic friendship, Walk in the Good Way, will be published soon by The Catholic University of America Press. You can follow him on Substack at Michael Pakaluk.