By Father Raymond J. de Souza
NOTE: One of the best things about being editor of The Catholic Thing is that I get to read authors like Father De Souza a day before you do. If you appreciate our writers as much as I do, you already know what I’m going to say next. They work for very modest remuneration, but their contributions are enormous. So please help keep this wonderful Catholic Thing going. You know the drill: there’s the button; you are TCT. – Robert Royal
St. Peter’s Basilica is the most Catholic thing in the world.
Its image, in an informational video or a movie scene, stands for the Catholic Church. EWTN, the world’s largest religious network, includes only the silhouette of Michelangelo’s dome, enough by itself to manifest Catholic identity.
Pope Leo XIV concluded his long journey home from South America—which included Argentina, instead of the homecoming trip Pope Francis never made—in time to be back at St. Peter’s on Wednesday, on the fourth centenary of the basilica’s dedication.
It is not Rome’s most important liturgical site: St. John Lateran is the cathedral of Rome. But it is the largest and the most impressively decorated. Every church functions as an analogous sacrament, a visible sign of the invisible reality of the Church. St. Peter’s, from dome to colonnade, does so on a scale so grand and with a beauty so unsurpassed that the whole world recognizes it.
It manifests the reality of the Church, in the world and for the world, to direct worldly eyes toward heavenly things. And it is very much of the world, marked by the various vanities and venalities of the very summit of the High Renaissance. Like Dante for the Italian language, or Shakespeare for the English, St. Peter’s is the pinnacle of sacred architecture and art.
The pilgrim knows he is visiting the best that has ever been built, and the best that will ever be built. It is of the world not only by its human origins, but because it is the best the world has to offer. Nothing greater will be seen on this side of Heaven; indeed, it exists precisely to allow Heaven to be seen from this side of earth.
At four hundred years, St. Peter’s is not even half the age of its predecessor, the first St. Peter’s, which lasted more than a thousand years. The origins of the earlier church, under the worldly power of Constantine, reflect the Christian insistence that it matters supremely where God traced His finger in the world. In 326, thirteen hundred years before the dedication of the present St. Peter’s, Constantine and his mother, St. Helena, ordered the Church of the Holy Sepulchre to be built in Jerusalem.
The first St. Peter’s was built precisely over the relics of Peter, venerated on the same Vatican hill where he was crucified. It was the triumph of the particular over the practical. Building St. Peter’s over St. Peter involved leveling much of the hill itself, when very nearby there was already a comfortable imperial circus, flat and ready. But Peter was not crucified there, and the difference between here and there is the story of salvation.
By 1503, when Pope Julius II was elected, the papacy was in poor shape. Pope Pius III, his immediate predecessor, reigned only twenty-seven days, even less than Blessed John Paul I in 1978. Julius was called il papa terribile, meaning both fierce and warlike. Yet he was not as terrible as Alexander VI Borgia, who died that same year, before Pius III.
The old St. Peter’s was also in poor shape, ruined after a millennium. Replacing so venerable a building seemed impossible. Just as only a Mussolini could raze the buildings surrounding St. Peter’s to open the magnificent Via della Conciliazione, Julius gave the order to demolish the old and build anew.
A certain tyrannical cast of mind is needed to do such things; and Julius’s mind is said to have thought of Julius Caesar when he chose his pontifical name. At his death a fierce satire on this would-be Caesar would appear—Julius exclusus, originally anonymous, but later revealed to be the work of none other than Erasmus himself—in which Peter shuts the gates of Heaven on his successor Julius. God builds with crooked timber and flawed marble.
Julius laid the foundation stone in 1506, two years before sending Michelangelo to work on the Sistine Chapel and Raphael to attend to the nearby rooms. Bramante would be the principal architect, the first in a series—which included Raphael and Michelangelo—over the following century, until Maderno completed the imposing façade.
There was forever inscribed the vanity of too many popes, for the central panel of the 1612 inscription does not honor St. Peter but “Paul V Borghese.” The “Prince of the Apostles” is relegated to the side. The present façade of St. John Lateran, completed a century later, is happily correct: “Christo Salvatori” is in the center, with Clement XII to the side.
Gian Lorenzo Bernini would take over as architect in 1629 and remain so for fifty years. He gave St. Peter’s its heart: the baldachin over the papal altar, which in turn is over the tomb of Peter; its head: the imposing Altar of the Chair in the apse, beneath the stained-glass window of the Holy Spirit; and its arms: the keyhole-shaped colonnade, extending the Church’s mission to the whole world. The concept of genius loci has its roots both in Roman paganism and in architectural design; no place on earth has been the seat of so much genius as St. Peter’s.
That genius included, in the judgment of R. A. Scotti, “the strength of Bramante, the grace of Raphael, the clarity of Michelangelo, and the theatricality of Bernini.”
Scotti titled his history of St. Peter’s simply Basilica. It is unique of its kind. He notes that the audacity of the construction, which “stops the heart and makes the soul soar,” was achieved only at the cost of an “enormous sacrifice”:
The Renaissance popes pawned the family jewels in the name of art, begged, borrowed, and splintered the Christian Church to build the basilica. The details changed, but the ideal remained constant: to build in stone a metaphor for the leap of faith that is at the heart of the Gospel of Christ.
Nearly right. St. Peter’s is not so much about leaping as about standing on firm, dazzling, and sacred ground. And it is not a metaphor. It is a sacrament.
About the Author
Father Raymond J. de Souza is a Canadian priest, Catholic commentator, and senior fellow of Cardus.