The bishops' radio cuts Argüello: neither the statement on 29-N nor the "rants that polarize"

COPE gave the inaugural speech of the Plenary six times and in none of them did it mention that the president of the Episcopal Conference expects a statement from the bishops on the elections

The bishops' radio cuts Argüello: neither the statement on 29-N nor the "rants that polarize"

On Monday morning, Luis Argüello opened the 130th Plenary Assembly of the Episcopal Conference with a speech that, in a couple of sentences, looked at the calendar. “We are in the middle of an electoral campaign,” he began, and explained that he would not make “a direct reference to the upcoming general elections, as I hope this Assembly can offer some statement on the matter.” It has been years since the bishops have guided the vote in a general election. In the same speech, the president of the Conference denounced the “rhetoric that polarizes intellectual, social, and media life with strong political implications” and the “dialectics of opposites, of friend-enemy, us or them.” He also spoke about abuse.

Argüello is no ordinary guest on the bishops’ radio station: he chairs the Conference that controls the broadcaster. The station devoted two morning teasers and six pieces throughout the day to him (at twelve, at one, at twenty to three, at two to seven, at eight and eight, and at seven past eleven), about seven minutes in total. He appeared in six saying that human dignity cannot be subject “to the sway of majorities.” He appeared in five saying that it “has no passport.” The family, fear of commitment, and the “fragmented view of sexuality” came up, and once, at midday and in his own voice, that the defense of life “from conception to its natural end is not a confessional interest but a goal of civilization.” In the noon newscast, even the “increase in hysterical aggression, full of disillusionment, rage, and indignation” was aired (in the next two versions, the aggression lost the “hysterical” part).

The campaign did not come up. The statement did not come up. The rhetoric, the friend-enemy, or the abuse did not come up. It was like praying the Our Father and skipping the part about offenses. The bishops’ radio station kept the citizens’ aggression and left out media life (which, after all, is the station’s own beat). Right after saying goodbye to Argüello, the noon newscast moved on to a network report on economy and employment “just two weeks before the general elections.” The elections existed. What did not exist was the bishops’ intention to say something about them.

It is worth being precise. It was not a partisan cut in the simple sense: the phrase about migrants was in the lead of five of the six pieces, and the defense of life was heard in Argüello’s voice. What was left out has something else in common. It speaks of the campaign, the media, or the Church itself. That is, of the house and its owners.

For the rest of the press, that was precisely the news. El Debate headlined that the Church “could issue a statement this week on the general elections of November 29”; elDiario.es spoke of “voting guidelines”; Religión Digital, of a note from the Conference ahead of the general elections; this outlet, of a statement the bishops are studying. The bishops’ radio station, which has a promotion on air saying “the general elections are lived on COPE” (it aired at eighteen past six and at seven past eleven), did not tell its listeners. In the week when the Episcopal Conference may say something about the vote, the Episcopal Conference’s station did not preview it.

There were more opportunities in the afternoon. At two to seven, a piece of almost two minutes recalled the Pope’s three calls during his June visit (return to Christ, defend human dignity, build a Church of communion) and urged “turning applause into concrete commitment.” It aired right after La Tarde signed off with a saying about spice that will not be reproduced here. At eight, on La Linterna, Ángel Expósito reviewed his campaign topics. “I can’t stand seeing the prime minister pretending to be a likable guy,” he said, and called putting him to dance a “nonsense.” Regarding the attacks on the PP candidate in Hernani, he recalled that “Otegi and his gang have been and are Pedro Sánchez’s most reliable partners” and asked: “Who are the fascists and the Nazis in this movie?” He ended with the “unprecedented exercise of flattery, submission, and adoration of the supreme leader or beloved leader” by Francina Armengol at a rally and with a “Can one be more of a sycophant?” Four minutes later, the La Linterna newscast reported on Argüello’s speech: dignity, majorities, the passport. The rhetoric that polarizes media life also did not fit this time.

On abuse there is no room for irony. Argüello said that “it is not an accessory chapter of our ministry, but part of the credibility of the Gospel we proclaim.” In six pieces on his radio station there was no room for that sentence.

The Plenary ends on Friday. If there is a statement, it will be news even on COPE. Meanwhile, the promotion keeps airing: “The general elections are lived on COPE.” What the bishops have to say about them, for now, can be read elsewhere.


“COPE, the bishops’ radio station” is a daily section of InfoVaticana. We listen attentively to our bishops’ radio station and tell you what we find: advertising, guests, language, what is said and what is left unsaid. COPE is 75% owned by Ábside Media, the company the Episcopal Conference created in 2020 with its shares and those of most dioceses. In addition, the Jesuits and Augustinians are part of the shareholder base.

Each Spanish bishop is personally responsible for what is broadcast on it.

Read also

Help Infovaticana continue informing