Father Benoît de Giacomoni, superior of the French province of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter (FSSP), met with Leo XIV at the end of the general audience on Wednesday, October 28. This is announced by the Fraternity itself in a text published on its French website, where it specifies that, “after a cordial exchange, the Holy Father blessed the Province of France.”
According to the FSSP, De Giacomoni took the opportunity of the meeting to present the Pope with three works: the thesis of Abbot Alban Cras on the mission of the Apostle Peter, a special issue of the magazine Tu es Petrus dedicated to the founding of the Fraternity, and the June 2026 letter to Friends and Benefactors. The statement does not detail the content of the conversation and is accompanied by photographs from Vatican Media.
A letter responding to the consecrations of the FSSPX
The June letter, which the provincial placed in the Pope’s hands, contains, according to Michael Haynes’ analysis in his newsletter Per Mariam, De Giacomoni’s response to the episcopal consecrations of the Society of Saint Pius X. In it, Haynes explains, the superior compares the situation of 2026 with that of 1988, the year the FSSP was born from priests and seminarians who did not wish to follow Archbishop Lefebvre, defends the existence of the Fraternity against criticism from some members of the FSSPX, and maintains that the FSSP accepts the legitimacy of the ordinary form of the Roman rite, the 1983 Code, and number 25 of the constitution Lumen gentium.
Haynes interprets the text as an attempt to present the FSSP as a “safe” alternative to the FSSPX, which in his view may have strengthened the Pope’s confidence in the Fraternity. This is the author’s reading, not a fact from the FSSP’s statement.
Third contact of the Fraternity with the Pope so far this year
The October meeting follows the private audience Leo XIV granted on January 19 to the superior general, Father John Berg, at the end of which he imparted a blessing that extended to all members of the Fraternity. Haynes adds that, together with the audiences of 2022 and 2024, these contacts point to a policy of allowing orders like the FSSP to grow as long as they accept the Magisterium and Vatican Council II, while Traditionis custodes remains in force, although it does not directly affect the Fraternity.
The news comes at a time of growth for the community. InfoVaticana reported that the FSSP now exceeds 600 members, with 410 priests and an average age of 39, and that Father Patrick Duverger, former superior of the FSSPX in the Benelux, has joined the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Peter in France.
Haynes warns, finally, that if the Pope speaks of “unity” without lifting the current restrictions on the traditional liturgy, he will weaken the meaning of his own words and deepen the division. This is the analyst’s assessment, which has not been commented on by the Holy See or the FSSP.