The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith returns to the scene with its second Doctrinal Note in just a few weeks. Following the still controversial Mater Populi Fidelis, now comes Una Caro, a comprehensive document—seven chapters and 156 paragraphs—that seeks to ground and propose monogamy as the Christian ideal in the face of the proliferation of alternative models of coexistence. Specola positively values the doctrinal effort, but points out with concern the nuances and silences that could become interpretive cracks just when the Church needs firmness.
A solid text… that avoids uncomfortable topics
As Specola points out, the document presents itself as a “praise of monogamy,” supported by Scripture, tradition, and Christian philosophy, and even enriched by literary references. Its clearly propositional purpose is to offer convincing reasons to embrace the exclusive and permanent union between a man and a woman.
Read also: Una Caro, Cardinal Fernández publishes a new text on monogamy
However, the absence of references to the Islamic world is striking. In a text that addresses polygamy directly and indirectly—both traditional and its new Western expressions—leaving out a cultural sphere where polygyny is still practiced is no small detail. For Specola, this silence limits the real scope of the analysis.
The Prefect’s responses: doctrinal precision with unnecessary additions
During the presentation of the document, Cardinal Fernández reiterated that Una Caro does not intend to address polygamy but to deepen monogamy. But questions about so-called “same-sex monogamous unions” forced him to clarify the obvious: in the Catholic conception, marriage exists only between a man and a woman, exclusive and indissoluble.
Specola highlights that, after stating the doctrine without beating around the bush, the Prefect always adds a nuance that opens other windows: possible values “in other contexts,” utilities for “other forms of union,” and even for “a relationship between friends.” An unnecessary addition that, according to Specola, generates noise where there should be silence.
A document worked on for months and part of a cycle that is closing
The Prefect himself acknowledged that the text was practically finished some time ago. Una Caro, the Note on Marian Titles, the study on the transmission of faith, and the work on women’s participation in ecclesial life form a set that closes the mandate received from Pope Francis. The Dicastery now expects to meet with Pope Leo XIV to define the next steps.
Read also: Msgr. Armando Matteo, secretary of the DDF, announces the end of Francis’s epistolary
The reference to Humanae Vitae: a timely reminder
Cardinal Fernández emphasized that there will be no changes to Humanae Vitae, highlighting the validity of its vision on procreation and the social consequences of the decline in birth rates. Specola celebrates this clarity, recalling that the doctrine of marriage and openness to life are non-negotiable and that the fruits of their non-compliance are evident in Western societies.
A defense of marriage that must be accompanied by certainties
For Specola, Una Caro is a valuable and timely document that reinforces the doctrine in a field where cultural confusion wreaks havoc. But precisely for that reason, it warns that any ambiguity, nuance, or phrase open to lateral interpretations can distort a message that should be unequivocal. The Church defends monogamy and the indissolubility of marriage; this document points in the right direction, but the moment demands total clarity without concessions.